Anime fandoms are celebrated for their enthusiastic communities; however, some have earned a negative reputation due to their gatekeeping practices, which often push away newcomers and casual viewers. This article delves into ten particular anime fandoms, showcasing how elitist mindsets and exclusionary behaviors foster toxic atmospheres.
These fandoms frequently impose unreasonable standards, such as requiring comprehensive knowledge of intricate lore or ridiculing those who appreciate adaptations. Such gatekeeping tendencies can dissuade potential fans and suppress a variety of viewpoints, ultimately eroding the inclusive essence that should characterize anime communities.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.
Naruto and 9 Other Anime Fandoms Known for Gatekeeping
1) Naruto
The Naruto fandom is infamous for its gatekeeping, often marginalizing new and casual viewers. Veteran fans sometimes perpetuate an elitist mindset, labeling individuals who haven’t watched the entire series or read the complete manga as “fake fans.”Casual enthusiasts frequently face mockery for their limited understanding.
Contentious discussions around character power levels and canon interpretations can become hostile, with aggressive attitudes dominating dialogue. This leads to a spread of misinformation and a lack of healthy debate, creating a charged atmosphere where only certain interpretations are valid, thereby excluding more casual participants.
2) One Piece
The One Piece fandom is notorious for its stringent gatekeeping, which often sidelines newcomers. Established fans anticipate a thorough understanding of the convoluted lore, terminology, and vast character roster, making it challenging for those just starting their journey. Critiques regarding the series’ pacing are often faced with hostility, and appreciation for less mainstream characters can result in ridicule.
On social media platforms, some fans label others as “fake”if they haven’t read the manga or missed out on inside jokes. Conventions and fan projects often cater primarily to long-term fans, creating a barrier for newcomers looking to participate comfortably.
3) Dragon Ball
The Dragon Ball fandom is often scrutinized for its intense gatekeeping, making it one of the more challenging communities within the anime world. Long-term fans may dismiss newcomers unfamiliar with series like Dragon Ball Z or Dragon Ball Super, fostering a sense of elitism. New followers often face exclusion due to perceived gaps in their knowledge base, in a climate dominated by “true fan”mentalities.
Online discourse can grow toxic, leading to vitriolic arguments about character abilities or plot arcs. Hardcore fans tend to ridicule casual viewers, creating a climate that discourages the enjoyment of the series. Resistance to change, particularly toward new adaptations, further alienates both new and casual fans.
4) Demon Slayer
The Demon Slayer fandom has earned criticism for its gatekeeping tendencies, leading to an exclusivity that can be unwelcoming to newcomers. Long-time fans often show disdain for those unfamiliar with the manga, and this rejection intensifies as an emphasis is placed on intricate canonical knowledge, creating hostility toward differing character opinions.
Inside jokes and memes further isolate those outside of the established group. Additionally, toxicity at fan events contributes to a culture that suggests only a select few can genuinely appreciate or discuss the series.
5) Attack on Titan
The Attack on Titan fandom has a troubling reputation regarding gatekeeping, making it one of the more challenging communities to approach. Established fans often display elitist attitudes, excluding those who lack in-depth knowledge of the manga or nuanced plot details.
Contentious shipping wars and online harassment further perpetuate negativity, as fans clash over different interpretations of character relationships and narrative arcs. Furthermore, there exists critique towards those who seem unable to navigate the series’ complexities. Such gatekeeping behaviors create a climate that discourages new fans from active participation and enjoyment.
6) My Hero Academia
The My Hero Academia fandom mirrors the gatekeeping and harassing behaviors present in other communities. Long-term followers often declare themselves as “true fans,”dismissing newcomers or those with contrasting viewpoints, thereby fostering an unwelcoming atmosphere.
The prevalent shipping culture around characters like Bakudeku adds another layer of toxicity, as fans often face backlash for their differing preferences. Some community members even share inappropriate content involving underage characters, raising serious ethical issues. This detrimental behavior on social platforms like TikTok and Reddit fosters hostility, deterring new fans and tarnishing the reputation of the fandom as one of the most problematic in anime.
7) Sword Art Online
The Sword Art Online fandom is similarly noted for its gatekeeping tendencies. Newcomers often find themselves scrutinized by established members, who question their commitment if they haven’t consumed every episode or lack awareness of key plot points.
Criticism of others’ tastes is commonplace, with fans branded as “fake”for enjoying certain story arcs or characters. Exclusionary language deepens the divide within the community, with some belittling individuals who only watch the anime and don’t delve into the light novels. Toxic comparisons with other series and harassment of dissenting opinions contribute to a hostile atmosphere that discourages active engagement.
8) Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure
The Jojo fandom tends to enforce a strict viewing or reading order that stifles newcomers’ exploration of the series. New fans often encounter harassment, spoilers, and contempt from veteran followers for lacking detailed knowledge. Shipping disputes and cultural rifts, especially between Japanese and English-speaking audiences, exacerbate the existing tensions.
Misunderstanding of thematic elements generates dismissive reactions, while the community’s negative side includes criticisms of creator Hirohiko Araki and instances of racism and colorism, contributing to a troubling environment that alienates many potential fans.
9) Tokyo Ghoul
The Tokyo Ghoul fandom presents a hostile setting for newcomers. Veteran fans often expect intricate plot comprehension and dismiss individuals who are less familiar. There’s a sense of elitism based on whether fans read the manga or only watch the anime, leading to hostility towards varied interpretations or criticisms.
Complex jargon and defensive attitudes from long-time members further alienate new participants. This behavior stifles dialogue, with fans insisting on a singular “correct”method to appreciate the series, ultimately making it one of the less welcoming anime communities.
10) Neon Genesis Evangelion
The Neon Genesis Evangelion fandom faces criticism for its prominent gatekeeping practices, often creating an unwelcoming atmosphere for newcomers. Fans impose strict standards regarding knowledge, claiming that only those who grasp obscure details can contribute to discussions. This behavior leads to mockery of casual viewers and intolerance towards differing perspectives.
Social media platforms exacerbate the situation, as fandoms clash over who qualifies as a “real”fan. Such actions dissuade new fans from participating, ultimately diminishing their enjoyment and engagement with the series.
Final Thoughts
The gatekeeping behaviors prevalent in anime fandoms like Naruto, One Piece, and Neon Genesis Evangelion obstruct inclusivity and deter newcomers. This elitism fosters toxic environments where casual fans feel uninvited, ultimately detracting from the joy of shared experiences. Promoting a more welcoming and open community is crucial to enhancing fan engagement across all anime cultures.
Leave a Reply