4 One Piece deaths that should’ve been fakeouts (& 4 fakeouts that should’ve been real)

Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece, a beloved manga and anime series, is renowned for its enthralling storylines, intricately designed fantasy realm, and memorable characters. Throughout its ongoing journey, the series has also seen its fair share of character deaths.

Within this complex world, there have been varying perspectives among fans regarding character deaths. Some have suggested that certain deaths were intentionally staged to heighten the story’s development, while others argue that characters who faked their deaths should have ultimately faced the consequences.

From Fiction to Reality: 4 One Piece Deaths That Shouldn’t Have Happened

1) Monkey D. Ace

Portgas D. Ace (Image via Toei Animation)

Despite being Luffy’s adopted brother, Portgas D. Ace met a tragic end while defending Luffy from Akainu’s attack during the Marineford War. This pivotal moment had a profound impact on Luffy and his crew.

Despite arguments from fans, it is believed that Ace’s death was rushed and did not fully explore the potential of his character. If he had survived, it could have contributed to his growth and had a significant impact on future plot developments, especially during the Wano Country arc. While his tragic death was a pivotal moment, some suggest that faking his death could have provided opportunities for deeper storytelling and character development.

2) Edward Newgate

The Battle of Marineford marked the end of Edward Newgate, famously known as Whitebeard, a remarkably strong pirate. By ultimately sacrificing his life, he displayed his unshakeable determination and dedication to his crew. Nevertheless, there are fans who question whether Whitebeard’s death could have been staged.

Despite fans’ belief that Whitebeard should have retired from piracy and become a mentor to the next generation of pirates, adding depth to the story, his courageous death still had a lasting impact on the world of One Piece.

3) Exploring Pedro’s Hobbies

Pedro was a courageous Mink who allied himself with the Straw Hats, fearlessly putting everything on the line. He stood by their side throughout the events of the Whole Cake Island saga. In a selfless act, he gave up his life in order to ensure the safe escape of the Straw Hat Pirates.

Although his death caused tension and contributed to character development, there are those who believe that faking his demise would have been a better choice. Keeping Pedro alive would have provided the opportunity to delve deeper into his background and he could have served as a mentor to Carrot.

4) Claude Monet

During the Punk Hazard arc, Monet, a former member of the Donquixote Pirates, met her end when Caesar Clown stabbed her heart. There are some fans who believe that her death could have been set up differently to allow for her redemption and a more significant role in the narrative.

Despite the potential for intriguing storylines with her Devil Fruit powers and ties to the Donquixote family, the outcome of her story has already been determined, leading to differing opinions among fans on whether a revival arc would have added value to the overall series.

The Ultimate One Piece Fakeouts: Moments We Wish Were Real

1) Pell Grants

Despite appearing to sacrifice himself during the Arabasta arc by detonating a bomb to save the kingdom, Pell, a member of the Arabasta Royal Guard, managed to survive. This turn of events sparked much controversy and debate surrounding Pell’s actions and survival.

Keeping Pell alive diminished the significance of his sacrifice and weakened the impact of the Arabasta arc. If Pell had remained deceased, it would have highlighted the high stakes of the conflict and emphasized the sacrifices made in the pursuit of justice.

2) Vivi’s Royal Advisor

Despite Igaram eventually being revived, his self-sacrifice still held emotional significance.

If Igaram had indeed died, it would have had a profound impact on Vivi’s personal growth, as she would have been forced to face the harsh realities of leadership and the sacrifices necessary for the greater good.

3) British Pound Sterling

Pound, the father of Charlotte Chiffon and Lola, initially intervened to shield his daughters from harm during the events of the Whole Cake Island arc. However, he was subsequently ambushed by Oven of the Big Mom Pirates. Despite the attack, the cover page stories later unveiled that Pound had miraculously survived his supposed demise.

Although his survival did provide some heartwarming moments, there are fans who believe that Pound’s fake death should have been a genuine one. This would have added a deeper emotional impact to the story, showcasing the extreme lengths that parents are willing to go to for their children.

4) Nico Robin’s Capture and Enies Lobby Incident

Despite Nico Robin ultimately overpowering Spandam and breaking his spine using her Devil Fruit powers in the Enies Lobby arc of One Piece, the chief of CP9 was shown to have survived the confrontation.

Despite the arc’s events, Spandam’s villainous nature was consistently displayed through his reprehensible actions, such as his mistreatment and capture of Robin. His downfall would have been a just resolution, bringing closure to Robin’s character development and providing retribution for her suffering.

Concluding thoughts

The incorporation of death in storytelling holds a significant impact, as it elicits strong emotions and propels the narrative forward. In One Piece, certain fans believed that certain character deaths could have been fabricated for character development or future plotlines. Conversely, some deaths that were perceived as fake could have been authentic, adding higher stakes and evoking even more intense emotional reactions.

It is a subjective matter whether the deaths in One Piece were meant to be fake or real. Viewers have become deeply invested in the characters and their stories. This further highlights the immense impact and complexity of the One Piece universe and its characters. As the show continues to captivate audiences, exploring themes of life, death, sacrifice, and redemption will continue to play a crucial role in the story.