American Murder: Hidden Evidence You Probably Missed

Despite the release of Netflix’s American Murder: Laci Peterson, the Peterson case continues to be scrutinized. However, there is a crucial piece of evidence regarding husband Scott that may have gone unnoticed.

On December 24, 2002, Scott Peterson reported his 27-year-old wife Laci missing. Laci was eight months pregnant with their first child, Conner, at the time.

The events that ensued triggered a widespread investigation that caused a sensation in the media, as the focus swiftly shifted to the lead suspect: Scott.

Upon the discovery of Laci and Conner’s remains washing ashore not far from where Scott had been fishing on the day of her disappearance, he was apprehended and subsequently charged with the homicides.

The case has generated considerable discussion for many years, primarily because the evidence was based on circumstantial evidence.

However, the guilty verdict was based on numerous unsettling details, which are thoroughly examined in Netflix’s latest docu-series.

Despite the overwhelming amount of information to process, it is important not to disregard the image of Scott’s fishing license, purchased on December 20, as it may seem insignificant at first glance.

Upon closer examination, it becomes apparent that the validity of this document is limited to only two days. Modesto police Detective Craig Grogan confirmed that it was completed for December 23 and 24, the exact timeframe during which Laci was reported missing.

The prosecution contended that this, along with additional information regarding Scott’s fishing excursion, suggested that it had been premeditated.

It is also important to consider another statement here. Scott had informed multiple individuals that he intended to play golf, his favorite sport, on Christmas Eve.

In American Murder, Modesto police detective Al Brocchini recounts how Scott told him during their first interview that he had initially intended to go play golf as he had planned to.

“According to Brocchini, he initially planned to go golfing, but due to the chilly weather, he changed his mind and opted for fishing instead.”

The documentary then transitions to real footage of Brocchini’s first interrogation of Scott, during which he inquires about the specific moment when Scott chose to go fishing instead. Scott responds, “I made that decision in the morning.”

In addition, Scott’s secret purchase of a boat and his research on San Francisco Bay tides in the days before Laci went missing, added to the growing suspicion surrounding him.

The prosecutors contended that the fishing excursion could not have been a spontaneous decision, given the amount of preparation that had been put into it, such as obtaining a fishing license for a specific date.

Despite the prosecution’s argument, Scott’s defense team presented evidence that he had purchased fishing licenses in the past. He continues to maintain his innocence and is currently pursuing a retrial.

You can currently stream American Murder: Laci Peterson on Netflix.