Baldur’s Gate 3: Inconsistent Companion Disapprovals Baffle Players

The companions in Baldur’s Gate 3 are known for their unpredictable disapproval of certain actions, causing confusion and frustration among players.

Baldur’s Gate 3 features a reliable group of companion characters, each with a concealed approval rating that is influenced by your in-game choices. Skillfully managing their approval or disapproval is crucial in achieving your desired romances and building strong connections in the game.

Naturally, there are certain rewards that are simply too irresistible and there are disapprovals that players will always choose. But if you are just as eager for approval as we are, it can be extremely aggravating when your favorite characters become angry, especially when their reasons seem unfounded.

On the Baldur’s Gate 3 Subreddit, players have recounted numerous frustrating and bewildering situations in which companions express disapproval of your choices. Notably, Karlach and Shadowheart are the primary culprits in these instances.

Baldur's Gate 3 Karlach and Shadowheart — Larian Studios

Look at them, they don’t know what they want.

While some actions in Baldur’s Gate 3, like Lae’zel approving of violence, have obvious consequences, others may be more confusing. One player in a Reddit thread shared their experience, stating, “For me, it was strange how Karlach disapproved of siding with the Duergar rebels against Nere, despite having just approved of confronting Nere moments earlier.”

It is worth mentioning that Karlach is not fond of slavers or malevolent individuals in general. Therefore, if you rebel against them, she should have no qualms. Our beloved Tiefling may be mysterious, but she is not the only perplexing ally.

“According to another user, who attempted to imitate Shadowheart, it would be wise to go along with the plans of the dangerous necromancer who resembled a zombie. However, when they actually followed through with Balthazar’s plan, they faced disapproval from the followers of Shar.”

Navigating Baldur’s Gate 3’s abundance of choices can be overwhelming, but it’s important to keep certain instances in mind. Whether you’re pursuing a romance with muscle mommy Karlach or goth girl Shadowheart, remember to consider these factors.