Black Butler: Ciel’s Revenge on Maurice Cole

The second episode of season 4 of Black Butler premiered on April 20, 2024, at 11:30 PM JST on Tokyo MX, BS11, and other television networks in Japan. In this installment, Ciel gains a strong reputation at the school in order to get closer to the four Prefects.

Despite being able to attend a prestigious event for the Prefects and their Drudges due to his success, an unforeseen incident crushed his expectations. Undeniably, the second episode of Black Butler season 4 brought an intriguing turn to the plot. It notably adapted chapters 69 and 70 from Yana Toboso’s manga.

Highlights of Black Butler Season 4 Episode 2: The P4 Invites Ciel to Swan Gazebo

In the second episode of season 4 of Black Butler, titled “His Butler, in Disguise,”Ciel Phantomhive starts off with an off-screen narration. He shares the traditions of the Public School regarding the Drudges and confesses that he is willing to make harsh choices in order to obtain his freedom.

After Ciel’s narration, the focus turns to Sebastian Michaelis, who details his daily routine as the disguised housemaster. Despite the significant responsibilities and pressure that come with his duties, he remains dedicated to fulfilling the requests of both his master and Ciel.

In the second episode of Black Butler’s fourth season, it is revealed that Ciel has been fulfilling all of Clayton’s requests in an effort to gain his favor. His ultimate goal is to become Clayton’s Drudge and gain proximity to the Prefects. McMillan is impressed by Ciel’s capability to successfully complete numerous tasks for Clayton.

Redmond, as seen in Black Butler season 4 episode 2 (Image via CloverWorks)

Despite his lack of knowledge, the boy has been delegating these tasks to his butler, Sebastian. At the same time, the four Prefects and their Drudges convene at Swan Gazebo, an exclusive location reserved solely for them. They converse about the exceptional abilities of the new transfer student, Ciel Phantomhive.

Despite being an Earl, Ciel’s exceptional talents never cease to amaze Clayton, the servant of Lawrence Bluewer. Clayton, along with others, believes that the young boy possesses extraordinary abilities to complete any task given to him.

In the second episode of season 4 of Black Butler, Gregory Violet reveals that Ciel had visited his house during the Drudge Hour. This information undoubtedly perplexes the other Prefects and Drudges, as they are unable to understand the reason behind it.

Gregory, as seen in Black Butler season 4 episode 2 (Image via CloverWorks)

Despite this, Redmond speaks up and suggests that Ciel should have been at his own house, given his position and social standing. As they continue to talk, Edward Midford, the assistant of Green Lion House’s Prefect, Herman Greenhill, reveals that Ciel is not only his cousin, but also engaged to his sister.

Ciel’s talents are highly praised and the Prefects are impressed by the exceptional narratives surrounding him. As a result, they extend an invitation for Ciel to join them at Swan Gazebo. Redmond instructs his Drudge, Maurice Cole, to inform Ciel to meet them at 2 PM the following day at the gazebo.

Despite knowing the truth, Maurice’s jealousy causes him to lie to Ciel. According to Black Butler season 4 episode 2, Drudge, who is known for his good looks, tells Ciel Phantomhive that the Prefects have arranged a meeting with him at Swan Gazebo at 4 PM.

Ciel’s Vengeful Quest Against Maurice Cole

Upon receiving the invitation, Ciel Phantomhive realizes that this is his opportunity to get closer to the Prefects. In order to make a good impression on them, he instructs his butler Sebastian Michaelis to prepare something that will impress them.

The next day at 4 PM, Clayton and Edward rebuke him for attending the invitation. Despite his explanation that Maurice had instructed him to come at that time, the Drudge pretends to be unaware. Ciel becomes aware of the truth, but is unable to find a way to prove Maurice’s deceit.

He goes back to his dormitory and confides in Sebastian about everything that happened. Ciel makes a promise to himself to make Maurice regret wasting his efforts. He instructs his butler to monitor Redmond’s Drudge and gather information about him.

Maurice Cole, as seen in the episode (Image via CloverWorks)

Despite being a Drudge, Maurice’s hands are as white as pure snow, which leads him to be suspected as a pathological liar. This suspicion is further reinforced by his tendency to resort to underhanded tactics, as seen in Black Butler season 4 episode 2 where he manipulates others into doing his work.

Despite being able to recognize the falsehood in Drudge’s statement, Ciel believes it would be more beneficial to seek out others who have also fallen victim to Cole’s deceitful tactics.

Sebastian Spies on Maurice Cole to Find His Other Victims

Sebastian, as seen in the episode (Image via CloverWorks)

After departing from Ciel’s dorm, Michaelis Sebastian starts to follow Maurice Cole. He observes the blond-haired boy enlisting the help of other students to complete his tasks, from organizing intricate information to creating an exceptionally elaborate meal. In return, he offers these students the false promise of transforming them into his servants.

Furthermore, Sebastian uses his influence to manipulate certain students, acting as a tyrant and coercing them into doing his bidding. One day, while browsing at the library, he comes across a shy but intelligent young man who has fallen prey to Maurice’s cruel schemes.

One of Maurice's victims, as seen in the episode (Image via Cloverworks) — One of Maurice’s victims, as seen in the episode (Image via Cloverworks)

According to the second episode of season 4 of Black Butler, the blonde-haired Drudge falsely portrayed him as a liar to everyone. However, Sebastian reassures him, stating that he does not view him as a dishonest person.

Afterward, the butler relays his discoveries to Ciel Phantomhive. As per Sebastian, Maurice delegates most of his Drudge responsibilities to fellow students. Nevertheless, Ciel is curious about his activities within the Red House.

Soma, as seen in Black Butler season 4 episode 2 (Image via CloverWorks)

Due to his inability to handle the task and Sebastian’s preoccupation with completing his errands, Ciel realizes he requires an additional pawn. It then occurs to him that there is someone who would be an ideal candidate for the Scarlet Fox house.

Despite his reluctance, the circumstances force him to extend an invitation to that individual. The second episode of Black Butler season 4 concludes with the arrival of Indian royalty, Prince Soma Kadar Asman, at Weston College. He is seated on an elephant and accompanied by a grand procession.