BLACKPINK’s Rosé Faces Criticism from Forbes Over New Single “Disappointing,” Fans React with Anger

Forbes Critiques Rosé’s New Single, Sparking Fan Reaction

On December 9, 2024, Forbes released an article titled “Blackpink Star Rosé’s New Single Disappoints, But Big Things May Be On The Horizon.” This piece delves into the performance of her recent pre-release single, “Number One Girl,” which came out following her hit song “APT.”and in anticipation of her upcoming solo album titled “rosie.”

Disappointing Chart Performance

Forbes characterized “Number One Girl” as a “disappointment,” noting its failure to make an impact on the key rankings that contribute to the Billboard Hot 100. The article highlighted that the single did not appear on any of the three major charts: Billboard’s Digital Song Sales, Streaming Songs, and Radio Songs.

The publication remarked on the unexpected nature of this outcome, stating, “That’s surprising, as almost every tune released by the members of some of the biggest groups in K-pop usually at least sells well enough to land on the first tally in that list.”

Fan Backlash and Discussion

The Forbes assessment has ignited fervent discussions among fans, many of whom have expressed their frustration and passionately defended Rosé. Supporters emphasized that “Number One Girl” faced substantial competition from popular holiday tracks. They also referenced the impressive achievements associated with her forthcoming album, “rosie.”

Insights from Fans

Netizens shared a variety of perspectives, illustrating their support for Rosé:

“It’s normal to select the track with the highest potential for the first release. Rosé promoting ‘APT.’ makes sense, and in terms of timing, it’s expected for ‘Number One Girl’ and ‘toxic till the end’ to receive less traction.”
“The mention of the Hot 100 seems misplaced. It’s challenging for K-pop solo artists to make this list, and Rosé is performing well with digital sales, despite the saturation from Christmas music.”
“Didn’t the Grammys just say that ‘rosie’ distinguishes Rosé from BLACKPINK and the wider K-pop scene? Instead of labeling her song as disappointing, let’s appreciate the artistry involved.”
“Rosé recently topped the search charts as the most sought-after Blackpink member globally, despite the various names she’s known by. The denial of her success is simply unfounded.”

Source & Images