Did My Hero Academia Enhance or Damage Studio Bones’ Reputation?

My Hero Academia is approaching its conclusion with the anime adaptation produced by Studio Bones, sparking discussions about the studio’s reputation in light of this series. Many fans express a sentiment that the studio has not adequately honored the original material, particularly concerning the animation quality and action sequences.

Overall, devotees of My Hero Academia have voiced concerns that the recent seasons carried out by Studio Bones haven’t fully captured the essence of their beloved series. However, the situation is more nuanced than it seems. This studio has played a significant role in the franchise’s rising popularity over time and has consistently produced high-quality adaptations that merit further recognition.

Disclaimer: This article contains spoilers for the series.

Assessing the Impact on Studio Bones’ Reputation Due to My Hero Academia

Shigaraki and Deku about to fight in the anime (Image via Bones).

The evolution of Studio Bones’ reputation tied to this series could be described as a “fall from grace,”primarily as the initial three seasons garnered considerable acclaim from fans. These early seasons played a crucial role in elevating the franchise’s visibility and success; however, a noticeable shift began with the fourth season.

During this time, Bones’ creative team implemented various changes coinciding with an increase in detail in author Kohei Horikoshi’s art style, which did not favor the adaptation. A prime example of this is Mirio Togata’s post-Quirk loss battle against Overhaul, depicted through still frames rather than dynamic movements, a choice that remains controversial among fans.

It can be argued that Studio Bones’ reputation has become increasingly polarizing due to their work on this franchise, with suggestions that their focus shifted towards profitability. This stands in contrast to their approaches in other adaptations such as Fullmetal Alchemist, Soul Eater, and Mob Psycho, which showcase different creative strategies.

The Highs and Lows of Studio Bones with My Hero Academia

All Might's final battle in Kamino in the anime (Image via Bones). — All Might’s final battle in Kamino in the anime (Image via Bones).

As noted previously, Studio Bones has witnessed a downturn in its reputation with recent seasons of My Hero Academia, with some fans even criticizing aspects like the portrayal of the sky’s color in the latter war arcs. While their reputation may not be irreparably damaged, it has certainly encountered challenges.

Nonetheless, it is essential to recognize that Bones has created some memorable moments throughout this adaptation. Fights such as All Might’s clash against the Nomu in the first season and against All For One in the third season have received widespread praise, along with Deku’s short but impactful encounter with Katsuki Bakugo in season three.

However, there have been notable shortcomings too, particularly the notorious fifth season, which focused heavily on the Class A versus Class B arc at the expense of the highly regarded My Villain Academia arc. This shift may have marked a turning point for many fans and contributed to a perceived decline in the franchise’s popularity, especially as the animation quality often fell short of Horikoshi’s intricate illustrations in the manga.

Concluding Thoughts

The task of adapting My Hero Academia was never easy for Studio Bones, and the final product has certainly divided opinions. Ultimately, this anime adaptation has been beneficial for both parties, as it significantly increased the franchise’s global popularity and proved to be a commercial success for Bones.

Source