Emilia Pérez’s Oscar Prospects: Success Amid Controversy

If you tuned in for the Golden Globes last night, you likely witnessed Netflix’s film Emilia Pérez garner an impressive eight awards. However, the authenticity of this recognition appears to be under scrutiny.

For those unfamiliar, Emilia Pérez can be described as a modern Spanish dramedy that unfolds in the world of a male drug lord named Manitas (played by Karla Sofía Gascón). This character undergoes a medical transition into the enigmatic, philanthropic wealthy woman known as Pérez, aided by her lawyer Rita (Zoe Saldaña). The film is interspersed with surreal musical performances, including a notably controversial number that has gone viral on social media, addressing the theme of transition in a provocative manner.

Unpacking the Themes of Emilia Pérez

In the realm of mainstream media, Emilia Pérez takes a bold stance, tackling topics many prefer to avoid in 2025, particularly the significant issue of transgender representation. The narrative doesn’t shy away from the bloody realities behind Manitas’ criminal undertakings, immersing the audience in her intense journey that involves complex relationships and harrowing circumstances, including being kidnapped by the mob.

Upon its release a few months ago, Emilia Pérez left audiences perplexed. Its current Letterboxd rating stands at a modest 3.0, while Rotten Tomatoes displays a split critical consensus. As the awards season unfolds, public opinion appears to be shifting, with many expressing that the film does not merit its accolades.

Is the Praise for Emilia Pérez Justified?

Emilia and Rita in Emilia Perez — Netflix

Having attended its UK premiere in London, I found Emilia Pérez lacking resonance. Many in the audience appeared to share this sense of confusion. To delve into the film’s shortcomings, we must consider critiques from the trans and non-binary communities. Although I belong to a different segment of the LGBTQIA+ spectrum, I couldn’t help but feel the film undermined the true essence of the trans experience. With such a crucial representation finally presented, the film seemed to equate issues of identity with themes of criminality in a rather crude manner.

Critic Juan Barquin reflects this sentiment, stating, “Even if it wasn’t a regressive picture masquerading as progressive… Emilia Pérez would simply be a boring one, and that’s just as much a crime.” This highlights the responsibility we have, both as industry professionals and avid film enthusiasts, to heed the voices of trans individuals in evaluating whether this film achieves its objectives.

Despite these critiques, lead actress Gascón shines as a standout performer, and her recognition is well-deserved. However, such accolades cannot overshadow the film’s overall impact, particularly regarding its portrayal of trans narratives.

Karla Sofia Gascón and Zoe Saldaña in Emilia Perez — Netflix

From the Golden Globe results, two main points emerge: it is likely that Emilia Pérez may replicate its success at the Oscars, and we must critically examine the reasons behind this phenomenon. While the film has struck a chord with certain audiences, it’s essential to recognize the heavy criticism from trans voices who have pointed out its numerous flaws.

Next Best Picture writer Brendan Hodges notes that Emilia Pérez allows voters to feel self-satisfied by endorsing a project perceived as bold and socially aware, despite many viewing it as lacking substance. This raises concerns about whether awards are given out of genuine appreciation for the narrative, or simply as a means for voters to feel like champions of social progress.

As we navigate an increasingly polarized political landscape, representation remains vital. However, we must resist tokenism, ensuring that the spotlight on trans stories is handled with authenticity and respect. If awards voters are selecting Emilia Pérez to boost their own narratives rather than genuinely supporting the film, it does a disservice to those whose stories deserve to be told accurately.

You can currently stream Emilia Pérez on Netflix. Take a look at other major releases and find out what films are trending in our roundup of the top movies of 2024.

Source & Images