Explained: The Origin of Whitebeard’s Scar in One Piece

The enigmatic history of Whitebeard Newgate, renowned as One Piece’s most formidable character, raises intriguing questions, particularly regarding the scar on his face. Fans are deeply engaged by the mystery surrounding the individual capable of leaving such a mark on this powerful figure. Whitebeard’s dramatic exit during the Marineford arc not only reverberated throughout the One Piece community but also underscored his essential role in the narrative, especially with his revelation concerning the existence of the One Piece itself.

This article will delve into the most widely discussed theory regarding the identity of the person responsible for inflicting the wound on Whitebeard. Please be advised that potential spoilers from the manga will follow, so tread carefully if you are not up to date.

1. What’s the Origin of Whitebeard’s Scar?

Whitebeard prominently displays a large scar across his chest, a characteristic that has intrigued fans since it was first mentioned in chapter 434. During a meeting with Shanks, Whitebeard noted that Shanks’ features reminded him of the person who gave him this notable scar. This connection introduces fascinating speculation about Shanks’ lineage.

garling — One Piece: Figarland Garling | Source: MangaPlus

It appears that the individual responsible for Whitebeard’s infamous scar must resemble Shanks, leading us to consider either his brother, Shamrock, or their father, Figarland Garling. Given the length of time Whitebeard bore the scar, it is improbable that Shamrock inflicted it, as both he and Shanks were too immature to have engaged in battle with Whitebeard. Thus, it stands to reason that Garling was the one who delivered this formidable wound.

2. The Misconception About Roger

When Whitebeard drew the connection between Shanks and the individual who marked him, many in the audience promptly assumed that he was referring to Gol D. Roger, given Shanks’ connection as Roger’s most loyal subordinate. However, this interpretation is misleading.

While Roger was indeed a formidable pirate capable of leaving a scar on Whitebeard, evidence suggests otherwise. In all instances following their encounter—notably their battle at God Valley 38 years ago—Whitebeard did not exhibit any scars. Consequently, it’s reasonable to conclude that Roger cannot be credited with giving Whitebeard his scar.

3. The Potential Motive of Garling

Figarland Garling, a key antagonist within the One Piece universe, serves as one of the five elder stars who supervise the World Government, holding the esteemed title of the Warrior God of Science and Defense.

Tweet Loading…

The discovery of a Poneglyph at Fishman Island, 25 years prior to Whitebeard’s demise, may have catalyzed a confrontation between him and Garling. Fishman Island, under Whitebeard’s dominion, posed a significant threat to the World Government, prompting Garling’s mission to secure the Poneglyph and prevent any potential leaks regarding its secrets. Thus, it is entirely plausible that Whitebeard sustained his scar during this encounter, as Garling, serving as the supreme commander of the God’s Knights, possessed sufficient power to wound Whitebeard.

4. Overview of One Piece

One Piece is a critically acclaimed manga series crafted by Eiichiro Oda, serialized in Shueisha’s Weekly Shōnen Jump magazine since July 22, 1997.

The narrative centers around the ambitions of the Pirate King, Gol D. Roger, who proclaimed as his final words, “My treasures? If you want it, I’ll let you have it. Look for it; I left all of it at that place.” These declarations inspired countless individuals to venture out to sea, igniting a quest for the legendary One Piece.

Determined to claim the title of the world’s greatest pirate, young Monkey D. Luffy sets sail toward the Grand Line, accompanied by a diverse crew that includes a swordsman, marksman, navigator, cook, doctor, archaeologist, and cyborg-shipwright, embarking on a memorable adventure.

Source & Images