Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare has arrived on Netflix, leaving viewers with a pivotal question: what motivated Simran Bhogal’s actions?
To address this, we must delve into the complexities of the case highlighted in this true crime documentary. Adapted from the podcast of the same title, Sweet Bobby follows Kirat Assi, who is regarded as the victim of the UK’s longest catfishing scheme.
For nearly a decade, she was led to believe she was nurturing a genuine friendship that evolved into a romantic relationship and even an engagement with a doctor named Bobby Jandu. Throughout this time, Kirat was psychologically manipulated, alienated from her loved ones, and ensnared by a convoluted web of deceit.
This sophisticated scheme involved numerous individuals connected to both Kirat and the alleged Bobby. The revelation of the truth took everyone by surprise, so be warned that spoilers lie ahead if you’re not already acquainted with the story!
What drove Simran Bhogal’s actions?
Two primary theories emerge regarding Simran’s motivations, starting with a “craving for control and manipulation.” It’s evident that her actions were deceitful, whether intentional or not.
Simran has been portrayed by an actor in the series
As depicted in Netflix’s Sweet Bobby, unlike other catfish scenarios, Bobby did exist in reality, along with his wife Sanj and brother JJ, who Simran had previously dated. However, the personas that Kirat interacted with were actually Simran and her cousin, who continuously supported her as Kirat’s life unraveled.
Simran invented identities that made Kirat believe Bobby suffered serious life events, including being shot in Kenya and entering witness protection in New York. Over time, their virtual relationship grew romantic, leading Kirat to agree to engage with him.
As the fictional Bobby increasingly exerted control over Kirat, her mental health and job began to suffer. Simran also orchestrated a network of 60 fake identities, impersonating friends and relatives on Facebook, who consistently interacted with Kirat.
This perplexing catfishing incident raises the pivotal question: why did Simran engage in such behavior? When Kirat confronted her about these deceptions, Simran reportedly responded with a grim admission that she had “ruined her own life” without any visible emotion.
“One prominent theory suggests that her actions stemmed from a need for control and manipulation. By fabricating a false identity, she could emotionally isolate Kirat, exerting significant power over her. Such manipulation often arises from deeper psychological needs, enabling the deceiver to find fulfillment in areas where they might feel lacking in their own lives.”
This aligns with Simran’s comments regarding the case. While she was offered an opportunity to participate in the Netflix documentary, she declined but mentioned that “these events date back to my school years.”
Dr. Estevez highlighted another possibility, indicating that “Bhogal might have been seeking an escape. By embodying different personas, she could flee from her reality and inhabit a lifestyle she deemed unattainable.”
“This pattern isn’t uncommon among those grappling with self-esteem and identity troubles, as they may find it easier to connect with others through a constructed image.”
“Lastly, it’s critical to consider that Bhogal likely understood Kirat’s vulnerabilities well. Knowledge of Kirat’s relationship issues might have facilitated Simran’s manipulation, leveraging their family bond to uphold the ruse for so long.”
The catfishing scheme persisted for nearly a decade
Further insights on the case came from Shenella Karunaratne, a licensed counselor from Online MFT Programs, who noted, “The psychology behind catfishing can be intricate, given the variety of reasons behind such behavior.”
“In my experience, it often arises from feelings of loneliness or boredom, prompting individuals to adopt the identities of those they perceive as more appealing or successful.”
While catfishers may also emerge from “an unhealthy infatuation with an idealized figure,” this seems implausible in this situation since Simran was Kirat’s cousin and a prominent figure in her life.
Understanding the psychology of catfishers
Dr. Estevez elaborated on various “motivations” driving individuals to engage in catfishing. Reports indicate that approximately 20,000 victims fall prey to catfishers in the United States each year, underlining the significance of this issue in our digital landscape.
The motivations behind catfishing are multifaceted
“Emotional fulfillment is a major factor. Many catfishers find it difficult to build real-life connections, prompting them to create alternate identities online for a more appealing self-presentation,” Dr. Estevez shared. “The anonymity provided allows them to form relationships that might be challenging to establish otherwise.”
Psychological gratification also plays a role. “For some individuals, the thrill of deceiving others can be exhilarating, granting them a sense of power over someone else’s feelings. This manipulation can be compelling and, at times, even addictive,” she added.
“Finally, it’s common for catfishers to try and evade their personal issues. They may deal with social anxiety, insecurities, or past traumas that hinder real-life engagements. Adopting a different persona enables temporary escape from their struggles, albeit at the cost of another person’s trust and emotional welfare.”
“Understanding these motivations illuminates the intricate psychological forces at play in catfishing scenarios, emphasizing the substantial impact these deceptions can have on victims.”
What is Simran’s current status?
According to MailOnline, as of 2021, Simran Bhogal was residing with her parents in North West London. She has maintained a low profile following the scandal, with scant online presence.
This is a fictional account created for the documentary, not Simran’s actual Facebook profile
The article reports that she worked in financial services. However, in the concluding episode of the Sweet Bobby podcast, host Alexi Mostrous revealed that he and the Tortoise team managed to reach her.
“I discovered that Simran is no longer in her high-profile position; sometime between August and the podcast’s release, she exited her job,” Mostrous stated. “While the reason for her departure remains unclear, it could signify an attempt at accountability for her actions.”
Her lawyers issued a statement reflecting similar sentiments to those she shared with Netflix, asserting, “This matter revolves around a family dispute over events that commenced over ten years ago when I was still a schoolgirl. I regard this as a private family situation that has been resolved, and I vehemently contest the numerous unfounded and defamatory claims made against me. I also object to the disclosure of private matters to the media.”
Despite admitting her wrongdoing, Simran has yet to face any charges or prosecutions from law enforcement on behalf of Kirat, Bobby, or any of the individuals whose identities she impersonated. However, following an extensive legal battle lasting 18 months, Simran was instructed to compensate Kirat and issue a formal apology.
Kirat Assi’s journey post-catfishing
After navigating the traumatic catfishing experience and legal proceedings, Kirat Assi has successfully rebuilt her life, returning to her role as a radio show host. Now residing in London, she utilizes her experiences to raise awareness about catfishing, stalking, and identity theft.
Kirat is in the process of rebuilding her life
The distressing nine-year ordeal profoundly affected her. Kirat, who aspired to marriage and motherhood, initiated contact in 2009 at the age of 29, with the manipulation enduring until 2018.
As articulated in Sweet Bobby, “Simran has taken the most significant years of my life from me. At 44, I’m striving to regain control of my life. The possibility of becoming a mother weighs heavily on my mind; given my age, it’s a daunting uncertainty. Ultimately, however, I must take responsibility for my future, whereas Simran never will.”
On the subject of online safety, Kirat remarked, “While catfishing may be trivialized as a fun pop culture concept, it’s a source of significant distress for victims. I aim to dispel stigmas and protect victims from public shame.”
“We must understand that the internet needs regulation. I’m not seeking pity; I’m advocating for accountability and change.”
Bobby Jandu’s current situation
Bobby Jandu currently resides in Brighton with his wife Sanj and their son, where he works as a skilled dental surgeon. He appears in Sweet Bobby to recount the experience of having his identity stolen for nearly a decade.
Bobby strives to lead a normal life
One astonishing aspect of this true crime narrative is that Simran appropriated not only Bobby’s identity but also that of his wife and brother, enabling her manipulation over Kirat. Knowing Kirat’s desire for children, Simran even shared images of Bobby’s actual son, misleadingly suggesting Kirat would have a substantial role in his upbringing.
After the truth surfaced, Simran messaged Bobby to express her regrets while requesting that he refrain from involving the police. He recounted in the documentary, “I told her, ‘I will not keep anything from law enforcement, and thank you for coming clean. Best of luck.’”
Kirat’s lawyer later provided Bobby and Sanj with a comprehensive dossier detailing Simran’s online activities. Bobby explained, “He handed me a folder… containing evidence of an extensive scheme to convince Kirat that an extravagant version of me existed, which was entirely untrue.”
“We’re merely an ordinary family living a regular life. That revelation was even more shocking than Simran’s confession.”
You can now watch Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare on Netflix. For more true crime insights, check out episodes from Worst Ex Ever, delve into the unsaid story of the Menendez brothers, and explore the most astonishing moments from Mr. McMahon.
Leave a Reply