Exploring Nicholas Scratch’s Father: The Story Behind “Agatha All Along”

In the gripping finale of Agatha All Along, audiences finally discover what fate befell Agatha Harkness’s son, Nicholas Scratch. However, one significant inquiry lingers: Who is Nicholas’s father?

Initially introduced as a formidable antagonist in WandaVision, Agatha Harkness evolves into a complex anti-heroine by the conclusion of Agatha All Along. In a surprising twist, she collaborates with Billy (also known as Wiccan) from the afterlife to search for his long-lost twin brother, Tommy. This unexpected alliance hints at Agatha’s layered character development.

It’s crucial to note, though, that Agatha’s redemption arc is not entirely conclusive. Her past is marred by the chilling legacy of centuries spent ensnaring and murdering covens of witches through the lure of the Witches’ Road ballad. When her plans failed—a recurrent occurrence—she would siphon their powers, leading to her cold demeanor.

What Transpired with Nicholas Scratch?

Tragically, Nicholas Scratch met his end in his slumber, claimed by Death itself.

Nicholas Scratch walking away with Death — Image Credit: Disney+

The narrative unfolds in 1750, where a pregnant Agatha ventures through the woods, preparing for childbirth. The appearance of Rio—known as Death, the Original Green Witch—signals a grim fate: her child has perished within her. Agatha pleads for her son’s survival, vowing eternal animosity toward Rio should her plea fail. In a rare act of compassion, Rio grants Agatha an unspecified duration of time to bond with Nicholas, allowing him to experience a fleeting childhood.

Yet, the birth of Nicholas disrupts the natural order, and ultimately, Death returns to claim him. In an emotionally charged scene, Nicholas wakes and bids his mother farewell with a gentle kiss on her cheek before departing, leaving behind only his lifeless form.

Who is the Father of Nicholas Scratch?

While the identity of Nicholas Scratch’s father remains unconfirmed, several intriguing theories abound.

Nicholas Scratch as a baby in Agatha All Along — Image Credit: Disney+

Spontaneous Creation Theory: Much like Wanda Maximoff’s magical conception of Tommy and Billy, it’s possible that Nicholas was born through a form of “spontaneous creation.”In this context, Agatha may have harnessed her powers to conceive without traditional means, as hinted in the finale when she states, “I spoke no spell, I said no incantation… you were made from scratch.” This could imply a birth devoid of magic, adding complexity to his origins.
Death as the Father: Considering Rio’s embodiment of Death in the series, it’s conceivable that Death itself is Nicholas’s progenitor. Since universal forces transcend human traits, there’s a possibility that Death and Agatha shared an intimate connection, resulting in Nicholas’s conception. This interpretation adds gravity to Nicholas’s demise, as Agatha laments, “It cannot be,” to which Death counters, “It must be.”
Mephisto’s Involvement: Some speculate that Mephisto could be Nicholas Scratch’s father. Although the name might invoke skepticism among fans, his mention in Agatha All Along stirs curiosity. The nickname “Old Scratch,” often associated with the Devil, raises questions about the true nature of Nicholas’s heritage.

As fans await potential revelations in a possible Season 2 of Agatha All Along, these theories provide food for thought and speculation regarding Nicholas’s origins.

Source & Images