Exploring the Illusions in Alfonso Cuaron’s Disclaimer: Why Nothing Was As It Appeared

Alfonso Cuarón’s Disclaimer concludes in a manner that reshapes the entire narrative trajectory of this Apple TV+ drama series. This seven-part show, both written and directed by Cuarón, draws inspiration from Renée Knight’s 2015 novel of the same name, immersing viewers in a compelling dual-timeline story.

The narrative unfolds in two distinct eras: the past, where Catherine Ravenscroft embarks on a brief romantic liaison with a young man named Jonathan during a holiday. Tragically, the following day, Jonathan sacrifices himself to save Catherine’s son, Nicholas, losing his life in the process. In the present timeline, however, a novel emerges that depicts these harrowing events, leading to the unraveling of Catherine’s life as dark truths come to light.

Cate Blanchett delivers a gripping performance as the modern-day Catherine, while Kevin Kline plays Jonathan’s father, Stephen. The tension culminates in the series finale, where Catherine confronts Stephen in his kitchen, revealing her harrowing truth, unaware that her tea is laced with a lethal drug.

Warning: SPOILERS AHEAD – some content in the following sections may be distressing for certain viewers.

Understanding the Ending of Disclaimer

The narrative that Catherine shares is not merely a tale of passion but transforms into a horrifying account of sexual assault. In a shocking twist, it is revealed that Jonathan broke into her hotel room and assaulted her during a three-hour ordeal. Catherine clarifies that while Jonathan heroically saved Nicholas the next day, she failed to report the incident due to the trauma experienced the previous night.

Stephen’s disbelief prompts him to leave Catherine unconscious on the kitchen floor, while he rushes to the hospital with malicious intent toward Nicholas. However, upon reaching the hospital room, Stephen encounters a moment of hesitation when Nicholas, awake and aware, asks for his mother. This encounter becomes pivotal for Stephen as he grapples with his choices.

“I wanna go, please,” Nicholas says, which stirs something deep within Stephen, leading to a change of heart that ultimately allows him to empathize with Catherine’s plight.

Catherine and Robert in happier times in Disclaimer. — Catherine and Robert in happier times.

Meanwhile, Catherine reunites with her husband, Robert, portrayed by Sacha Baron Cohen. Stephen has seemingly conveyed the truth to Robert, leading to a tense confrontation where he expresses both remorse and understanding towards Catherine. Yet, sadness pervades as it’s evident the damage to their marriage is irreparable; Catherine feels hurt that Robert copes with her assault more effectively than her alleged affair.

In a poignant final act, Stephen incinerates the explicit photographs that sparked the chaos, only to be haunted by the reflection of young Nicholas, revealing that he witnessed the traumatic event. As Stephen confronts his actions, a haunting narration echoes: “nothing can purify you, nothing can absolve you, ahead of you there’s nothing,” reinforcing the moral weight of the story.

The series concludes with a striking scene of Catherine and Robert’s divorce, yet hope emerges as she reconnects with her son. In a heartfelt exchange, they express their love for each other, underscoring themes of gratitude and resilience in the face of trauma. The show wraps up, leaving viewers with mixed emotions about the harrowing yet ultimately transformative experiences depicted throughout.

All seven episodes of Disclaimer are currently available for streaming on Apple TV+. For recommendations on other must-watch series, check out our curated list of the best shows on Apple TV+.

Source & Images