Frieren’s Reign: Has Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Been Dethroned Forever?

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a renowned masterpiece. Even after almost 15 years, it remains a beloved fan-favorite. The anime encompasses elements of Adventure, Dark Fantasy, and Steampunk, making it appealing to a diverse audience.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood captivates audiences of all ages and interests with its engaging narrative that covers a wide range of themes. Whether one is a fan of action, science fiction, or a dedicated otaku, Brotherhood offers something for everyone.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood has been a top-ranked anime for almost a decade, holding its position as one of the best works on both MyAnimeList and Anime News Network. These reputable sources are trusted by countless anime enthusiasts worldwide for reliable information.

Despite being held in high regard and seemingly untouchable, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood was recently surpassed as the highest-rated anime after nearly ten years. This was due to the overwhelming success of a new anime, Frieren, which took the anime world by surprise in Fall 2023.

Has Frieren dethroned Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood forever?

Frieren, a Fall 2023 anime, has released 28 episodes. Its tropes are reminiscent of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood and it has received high ratings. However, as the current rating only reflects the first season, it is subject to change as future seasons are released.

Anime Ranking- Frieren at the top
Anime Ranking- Frieren at the top | Source: MyAnimeList

The impressive ascent of Frieren is certainly praiseworthy. However, history has taught us valuable lessons. Throughout the years, the renowned FMAB has encountered numerous competitors. Anime such as Bleach: Thousand-Year Blood War and Attack on Titan have amassed a large number of viewers and have been highly rated, earning the top spot.

Despite its fleeting nature, these rankings consistently place FMAB at the top due to its loyal fan base. Whenever Brotherhood’s position is challenged, its devoted followers rally to maintain its top spot. Therefore, it is highly probable that Frieren will also have to relinquish the top position to FMAB once again.

2. What contributed to FMAB’s long-standing top position?

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
The King of MyAnimeList | Source: Official FMAB Website

Despite being often ranked as one of the best anime of all time, FMA Brotherhood’s widespread appeal is the true reason for its consistently high ratings. It can be enjoyed by viewers of any age, gender, or genre preference.

Additionally, the English dub for the series is top-notch and it has a significant presence on popular streaming platforms such as Toonami, making it easily accessible for casual anime viewers. This has introduced many people to the world of anime, especially since the setting is not limited to Japan, making it appealing to a wider audience.

3. How did Frieren become the leader?

Freezing: Season 1
Frieren: Season 1 | Source: Official Frieren Website

Frieren is an intricately woven story that leaves little room for criticism. Its captivating plot, well-developed characters, and thought-provoking dialogue seamlessly blend fiction with our own reality.

In the story of Frieren, we are transported to a magical realm filled with elves, demons, and spells. As we follow the journey, we witness an elven sorceress who joins forces with the Hero Party to defeat the Demon King. Through this epic battle, she learns the value of authentic human connections.

The director, Keiichiro Saito, expertly captures the emotional undertones through his brilliant orchestration. The captivating musical score by Evan Call only adds to the overall quality of the work. With each episode reaching the pinnacle of anime, it is no surprise that Frieren has rightfully claimed its spot at the top.

4. Will Frieren stay at the top?

Frieren has a tough fight ahead
Frieren has a tough fight ahead | Source: Official Frieren Website

Despite its well-crafted story, Frieren may not remain in the top spot (and this has nothing to do with FMAB fans’ alternate accounts hating it). While it may not follow the conventional format, it could be challenging for a casual viewer (such as Shounen fans) to stick with it.

Although the slow pace and lack of action may be considered positives by experienced viewers, they can come across as dull for those unfamiliar with anime. However, with the impressive production of Madhouse and the potential for the second season to solidify Frieren’s place in the Top 10, it is worth giving the series a chance.

It is highly improbable for any anime to remain in the number 1 spot indefinitely. The best anime, in fact, is one that is universally loved, such as Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. However, there is also the possibility that the passionate fans of FMAB may overpower the popularity of other anime, as has happened before with Frieren.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *