Menendez Brothers Trial Reopening: Impact on Monsters Season 2

The news has circulated, everyone! The trial of the Menendez Brothers is being reopened, which undoubtedly raises numerous questions in our minds.

Will we finally get real-time closure to a true-crime docuseries? Or will the court of public opinion play its own hand? Let’s delve deeper!

Is the Menendez Brothers’ Trial Reopening?

The Menendez Brothers’ trial is set for a court hearing this coming November.

Looking back at the case’s history, Lyle and Erik Menendez were convicted in 1989 for the murders of their parents and subsequently sentenced to life imprisonment.

Recently, new evidence has come to light, prompting the investigation to be reopened. This new evidence could be pivotal in altering their conviction, potentially leading to a reduced sentence or even their freedom.

In a letter, Erik claims that he was a victim of sexual abuse by his father.

This revelation serves as a central defense for the brothers, asserting that the murder was an act of self-defense. The Los Angeles County District Attorney has confirmed that this new evidence is under intense scrutiny, reflecting a moral and ethical responsibility to investigate further.

What Does This Mean for Monsters Season 2?

Menendez Brothers in Monsters | Source: Netflix

The reopening of this investigation could significantly influence Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, a Netflix true-crime series co-created by Ryan Murphy.

The series unveils the tragic and unforeseen story surrounding the brothers’ crime, followed by their conviction.

Recently, Murphy expressed interest in continuing this narrative, not through a traditional second season but instead by adding a few extra episodes to the first season, contingent on the lead actors, Nicholas Alexander Chavez (Lyle) and Cooper Koch (Erik), agreeing to reprise their roles.

Will the Show Extend?

The success of the hearing and the actors’ willingness to return will likely dictate whether the show will be extended.

Murphy has hinted that a possible acquittal for the brothers could steer the story in an exciting new direction, worthy of exploration on screen.

Could This Bring Closure to Season 2?

If additional episodes are produced, they could furnish viewers with closure by chronicling the brothers’ experience through the reopening of their case. This might alter public perception of the Menendez brothers and their motivations for the crime.

Murphy’s commitment to revisiting the case highlights his intention to delve into the intricacies of the story further. Expanding Monsters would offer a rare opportunity to portray the trial’s outcome and its implications on the brothers’ lives in real-time.

This would also enable the creative team to enhance a real-life event as it unfolds.

Will The Lead Actors Return?

Fans are buzzing with anticipation to see Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Cooper Koch reprise their roles, given their outstanding performances in the first season.

However, their return hinges not just on Netflix’s decision to bring them back but also on their willingness to return, which would be fantastic for audiences.

Should this iconic duo reprise their roles for potential new episodes, the show could delve into the emotional intricacies represented by the brothers on-screen, providing a fresh perspective on their lives.

Their return would introduce a significant dimension to the series and afford it a chance to deliver a proper conclusion to the Menendez brothers’ narrative, a highly anticipated moment for true crime enthusiasts.

A Few Final Thoughts

Every true crime aficionado has been closely following Netflix with newfound hope since the trial’s reopening, anticipating an expansion of Monsters: Season 2. Given Netflix’s considerate approach towards its audience, an extension seems plausible.

If all aligns favorably and the actors choose to collaborate once more, we might finally receive the closure we’ve all been craving!

About Monster

Monster is an American biographical crime drama anthology television series created by Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan for Netflix. Both Murphy and Brennan serve as showrunners for the series, which explores the lives of “monstrous figures” , with each season focusing on different killers.

The inaugural season, The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, centers on serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer (Evan Peters) and premiered on Netflix on September 21, 2022. Initially intended as a limited series, it was renewed for a second and third season in November 2022. The second season, The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, delves into the infamous murder case of the Menendez brothers (with Nicholas Chavez as Lyle Menéndez and Cooper Koch as Erik Menéndez), and was released on September 19, 2024. Additionally, the third season, announced in September 2024, will focus on killer Ed Gein (Charlie Hunnam).

Source