Overwatch 2 Experts Argue That Marvel Rivals Show Blizzard Should Shift Focus Away from Balance

Recently, a discussion erupted among Overwatch 2 content creators on X, centering around the game’s current trajectory and the potential pitfalls of an excessive focus on character balance.

The atmosphere surrounding Overwatch 2 is particularly charged, especially with the emergence of Marvel Rivals. This new competitor has intensified pressure on Overwatch, leading many former players to abandon it for what appears to be a more engaging experience. Unlike transient trends, Marvel Rivals seems to have solidified its place in the gaming landscape.

A notable voice in this discourse is @YourOverwatch. Despite his dedication to Overwatch indicated by his channel name, he has largely shifted his focus to Marvel Rivals. His recent videos, such as “Overwatch is Cooked – Why Marvel Rivals wins” and “Is Marvel Rivals Better than Overwatch?” highlight his skepticism about Overwatch’s future.

The Delicate Balance of Overwatch: A Point of Contention

In a comprehensive post, YourOverwatch expressed that the game has lost its boldness, compromising its identity to pursue universal approval. This sentiment echoes concerns about recent balance changes, including the rework of Sombra and adjustments made to Widowmaker.

I’m rooting for OW. The new dev team really cares and is trying their best. But the patience and extra lives have run out. Real, high tier competition is finally here. I refuse to apologize for my “I told you so”grand tour. So much of the community thinks they had the right… https://t.co/KwnmoSWQlp

— Your Overwatch (@YourOverwatchYT) January 14, 2025

AVRL, a recognized Overwatch caster, shared similar sentiments. He questioned how the player base focused disproportionately on balance as a source of dissatisfaction, arguing that for most players, balance rarely plays a crucial role.

I don’t think I’ll ever fully understand how the entire OW player base was psy-op’d into talking about balance and pointing at balance as a root cause for grievances. The reality will always be that balance almost never impacts the vast majority of players. Individual player… https://t.co/vOHI83VFFi

— Kev Walker (@imAVRL) January 15, 2025

AVRL further noted that Marvel Rivals has garnered praise for its intentionally unbalanced character dynamics, where substantial disparities exist between stronger and weaker characters. He posited that achieving a perfectly balanced experience in hero shooters may not be feasible.

While Marvel Rivals has its share of balance-related criticisms—particularly concerning certain Strategist characters with overpowered ultimates—Spilo, an Overwatch coach, underscored that many prominent characters from the previous season required significant skill to utilize effectively.

The rise of Marvel Rivals as a leading title in the hero shooter genre has put Overwatch 2 under scrutiny. As the community voices growing concerns, players are increasingly calling for substantial changes from Blizzard to revitalize interest in Overwatch.

To remain competitive, Overwatch 2 may need to approach its design philosophy with renewed vigor, particularly in areas of character balance.

Source & Images