Reasons True Berserk Fans Should Avoid Supporting Studio Eclypse’s Fan-Made Project

Studio Eclypse, a fan-operated animation group, has gained attention for their undertaking to remake the late Kentaro Miura’s classic series, Berserk.

While this project has ignited considerable excitement, it has also sparked controversy and concern within the dedicated fan community. Here are several reasons why true Berserk enthusiasts should reconsider supporting this initiative.

Disclaimer: This article reflects the views and opinions of the author

Why endorsing Studio Eclypse’s Berserk could undermine Miura’s masterpiece

Guts as seen in Berserk 2016 anime (Image via Millipensee, Gemba)

A primary concern pertains to the legal implications. Studio Eclypse’s production has been officially labeled as unauthorized by Hakusensha.

Any content related to the Berserk franchise cannot be legitimately created or distributed by this studio. Supporting this project could be construed as endorsing copyright infringement, which jeopardizes the legal safeguards that protect creators and their works.

Copyright laws exist to protect artists’ intellectual property and ensure they receive proper recognition and compensation for their efforts. By backing an unofficial adaptation, fans may unwittingly contribute to a culture that diminishes these protections.

Statement from Hakusensha and its translation (Image via X)

To fund their project, Studio Eclypse has solicited donations via Patreon. While fan projects often require funding, accepting financial contributions for an unauthorized adaptation raises ethical considerations. It risks exploiting the fan community’s support for personal benefit while blurring the boundaries between a fan tribute and a commercial venture.

Previously, Studio Eclypse announced plans for a remake of Attack on Titan, titled ‘Attack on Titan: Requiem’, yet has failed to deliver substantial results. This raises doubts about their capacity to fulfill their commitments.

If they could not complete a well-known project like Attack on Titan, can they really do justice to Berserk? Fans should be cautious about investing trust and resources in a studio with an unproven history.

Supporters of this project may believe they are contributing to a genuine effort to honor Miura’s legacy.

However, without official permission, there’s no assurance that the donations are being utilized correctly. This situation creates a moral quandary for fans who wish to support the project while ensuring their contributions are ethically managed.

There is no guarantee that Studio Eclypse’s “faithful”adaptation will meet the lofty expectations established by Miura’s original work. Miura is celebrated for his complex storytelling and elaborate artistry.

Replicating his work necessitates extensive resources, including talented writers, directors, and animators. Fans could experience disappointment if the adaptation fails to capture the essence of the original series.

The passing of Kentaro Miura profoundly impacted the anime and manga community.

Backing unauthorized adaptations might be perceived as undermining Miura’s legacy and the efforts of Studio Gaga, the team that collaborated with him. True fans should honor Miura’s memory by supporting official releases that are endorsed by his estate and affiliates.

Berserk is a masterpiece that uniquely combines dark fantasy, rich character development, and philosophical depth. Miura’s narrative intricately weaves themes of struggle, sacrifice, and the human experience into a captivating and thought-provoking tale.

Fans who have followed Guts’ journey through the pages of Berserk recognize that the series’ significance lies in its deep storytelling and craftsmanship.

Unauthorized adaptations risk falling short of these standards, disappointing fans and potentially harming the reputation of the original material.

Conclusion

While enthusiasm for a new anime adaptation is understandable, true fans must consider the broader implications of backing Studio Eclypse’s unauthorized project. By prioritizing legal, ethical, and quality concerns, fans can play a vital role in ensuring that Berserk’s legacy is upheld and respected.

Promoting official releases not only pays tribute to Miura’s legacy but encourages studios and publishers to produce high-quality adaptations that stay true to the original work.

By making informed decisions, fans contribute to fostering a culture that honors and respects the artistic achievements of creators like Kentaro Miura.

Source