The Hidden Identity of Rings of Power’s King of the Dead Revealed

According to an intriguing theory regarding the Rings of Power, one character may eventually become the King of the Dead, a ghostly figure featured in the Lord of the Rings saga.

The placement of Rings of Power in the Lord of the Rings timeline has generated considerable speculation about how its narrative could extend into the Third Age.

For instance, is the Stranger genuinely Gandalf without his knowledge? And who is the enigmatic Dark Wizard, set to appear in Season 2? Could he possibly be Saruman or even one of the Blue Wizards?

Theo, the son of Bronwyn (who was written out of the show following the actress’s departure), has become the focus of various theories. During Season 1, fans speculated that he might evolve into the Witch-King of Angmar after discovering the Morgul Blade.

This particular theory carries more weight, considering the groundwork being laid by the showrunners: Theo may ultimately become the King of the Dead. While this may not occur immediately, it seems plausible over time.

On Reddit, a user noted Theo’s growing connection with Isildur, suggesting it sets the stage for the oath he swears. They indicated that his repeated emphasis on making and keeping promises hints at a future breach of his oath.

The King of the Dead has limited backstory in Tolkien’s original works. We know he lived during the Second Age and initially served Sauron before swearing fealty to Gondor, with Isildur as king.

He pledged to fight for Isildur when called, yet he was absent during the War of the Last Alliance. Consequently, Isildur cursed the King of the Dead and his followers, condemning them to dwell eternally in the Dwimorberg mountain.

The King of the Dead in Return of the King — New Line Cinema

“Arondir referred to him as ‘Lord of Pelargir.’ In the books, the Army of the Dead assists Aragorn in reclaiming Pelargir, presenting a potential redemption arc for him,” the Redditor added.

This theory is gaining traction, with many viewers expressing support. “I prefer this theory to the idea of Theo becoming a Nazgûl,” one viewer mentioned, while another agreed, saying they believe the narrative has been leading in this direction.

Another user commented: “Theo perfectly embodies the characteristics of the king of the dead, as his guilt over the destruction of his homeland positions him as someone unlikely to sacrifice a second home to fulfill an oath.”

“That’s a fascinating theory. Theo seems a bit moody and inept; I struggle to see him gaining enough respect to lead anyone, but perhaps he will mature quickly as the season progresses,” added a fourth viewer.