The anticipated release of the Netflix documentary about the Menendez brothers has finally come, offering new insights into how Erik and Lyle Menendez were apprehended.
This documentary, a true crime exploration, surfaced shortly after Ryan Murphy’s dramatization titled Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story. The drama revisited the infamous 1989 killings of their parents, Jose and Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez, at their Beverly Hills residence, as well as the high-profile trial that followed.
Similar to Murphy’s Dahmer series, the second season of Monster instigated controversy, with critics suggesting that it portrayed the brothers unfavorably. Particularly scandalous was the insinuation that Erik and Lyle may have shared an inappropriate relationship, a characterization that their family condemned as “pure evil.”
The documentary titled The Menendez Brothers presents a different narrative, incorporating perspectives from family members, jurors from the original trial, and the brothers themselves as they recount the events leading to their arrest. Please note: some viewers may find the themes distressing.
The Capture of the Menendez Brothers
Ultimately, Erik and Lyle Menendez were apprehended after their therapist, Dr. Jerome Oziel’s mistress, Judalon Smyth, revealed to authorities that the brothers had made taped confessions.
Prior to this, police had already begun investigating the brothers as potential suspects following a lavish spending spree. Initially, Lyle and Erik claimed they were at the movies on the night of August 20, 1989, providing an alibi to authorities.
Both Erik and Lyle were sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
In the weeks following the murders, the brothers splurged, spending hundreds of thousands on luxury items such as a Porsche Carrera, Jeep Wrangler, and expensive Rolex watches.
Erik abandoned his plans to attend UCLA, instead opting to hire a tennis coach for $50,000 a year. Lyle, on the other hand, purchased a restaurant near their former home in Princeton, New Jersey.
According to Los Angeles Times journalist Alan Abrahamson in the documentary, “Contrary to popular belief, police are not naïve. When the brothers began their spending spree, detectives wondered if there was a motive behind it.”
Reflecting on this tumultuous period, Erik stated, “The notion that I was enjoying myself is ridiculous. Everything was a facade to mask the immense pain of wanting to end my life.”
He continued, “The only thing that prevented me from taking my own life was the thought of failing my father.”
Lyle also shared, “I didn’t live the playboy life… I often found myself sobbing at night, struggling to sleep, and drifting aimlessly during those months.”
Lead prosecutor Pamela Bozanich appears in the documentary, explaining how detectives pursued the brothers as suspects even while they argued that the murders were likely connected to organized crime.
She highlighted the importance of locating the murder weapon to strengthen their case. “Eventually, the investigators traced it to San Diego,” she recalled. “They discovered where the guns were bought using a stolen ID from Lyle’s roommate. That was a pivotal moment for the case.”
Reports from that era indicated that the uncovering of the gun shop was revealed in May 1990, two months post the brothers’ initial arrests. Smyth had approached detectives on March 5, 1990, to disclose that her ex-lover and therapist Oziel had recorded confessions.
Following a search of Dr. Oziel’s residence under warrant, the authorities confiscated the tapes, leading to Lyle’s arrest on March 8. Erik, who was competing in a tennis event in Israel at that time, returned a few days later and surrendered himself to authorities.
While recounting his arrest in the documentary, Lyle expressed, “They could have simply called and asked me to come to the station. It felt like a media spectacle. They even alerted the press.”
He further added, “They made the arrest feel dramatic, like I was a dangerous criminal. Knowing the truth of my responsibility weighed heavily on me. There was a strange sense of relief upon being taken into custody.”
Lyle was arrested in March 1990.
Erik further remarked, “The moment I landed back home and was placed in handcuffs, everything changed. It marked the end of my life as I knew it. I was just a teenager, completely unaware of what lay ahead.”
Following their apprehension, the story transformed from a local affair to an international sensation, captivating headlines worldwide.
Advocacy Efforts by the Menendez Brothers
Netflix’s The Menendez Brothers dives into the aftermath of their arrests, revealing how Erik and Lyle have emerged as advocates for male sexual abuse survivors.
Additionally, they are actively pursuing their freedom, having filed a habeas petition in May 2023 to overturn their murder convictions, based on newly surfaced evidence that supports their accusations of abuse.
Lyle remains an advocate for those affected by sexual abuse.
The documentary reveals, “The judge requested a response from the District Attorney, and they are presently awaiting a ruling.”
A particularly controversial aspect of the trial was the judge’s refusal to permit expert testimony regarding the extensive sexual, physical, and psychological abuse the brothers claimed to have endured at the hands of their parents.
It is widely believed that the LA County District Attorney sought a significant win after the OJ Simpson trial, leading to heightened scrutiny and difficulty allowing Erik and Lyle’s experiences to surface.
The brothers convey how societal perceptions of male sexual abuse survivors were vastly different during their trials. Erik notes, “After revealing my experience, it felt as though no one was willing to acknowledge it.”
New evidence has surfaced supporting Erik and Lyle’s abuse claims.
Erik elaborated, “There was a pervasive culture of silence surrounding these issues, persisting until the 1990s. I believe it began to shift in the early 2000s.”
Lyle expressed that sharing the story brought him a sense of relief, as he received letters from other survivors willing to share their experiences.
He serves as a confidant for many inmates, who view him as a “safe space” to disclose their stories.
Understanding the “60-Day Decision”
After the debut of Monster Season 2, Talia Menendez, Erik’s daughter from his marriage to Tammi, provided an update on Instagram, indicating that an announcement on the habeas petition is anticipated soon.
Talia mentioned, “Within 60 days, we expect feedback from the LA County District Attorney’s office concerning their decision on Erik and Lyle’s plea for freedom, submitted last May.”
She added, “As everyone knows, there exists new evidence validating the years of abuse that were initially disregarded, which should have been included in the retrial.”
Talia continued, “I hope the DA and judge will exhibit compassion towards what my father and uncle have endured, as well as the desire of our family for them to return home. Almost 35 years is enough confinement. They have now spent more time imprisoned than living freely. Let that resonate. Free them!”
In response to a follower’s inquiry regarding the 60-day timeframe, family members managing Lyle’s Facebook page clarified, “That’s not accurate… We empathize with everything you’ve faced. However, please refrain from believing conjecture you find online.”
This situation might be confusing—while the follower presumed the 60 days referred to a potential release, Tammi mentioned they were simply expecting an update from the DA’s office.
As previously explained by one Reddit user, “What will transpire in 60 days is merely a determination regarding the approval of the habeas corpus by the DA. It does not indicate a release at this stage.”
“The legal proceedings are lengthy. If the DA approves the habeas corpus, the case will move to the magistrate judge. If the judge also approves it, multiple hearings will likely ensue.”
“This process could extend for years, and various points within the legal system hold the power to halt the habeas corpus at any stage.”
The Menendez Brothers documentary is currently available for streaming on Netflix.
Leave a Reply