The Way Home Season 3: Fans Discover Who Pushed Alice into the Pond

The premiere of The Way Home Season 3 Episode 1 left audiences stunned with the dramatic cliffhanger involving Alice being mysteriously pushed into a pond by an unidentified assailant. Although the identity of the attacker remains under wraps, it hasn’t stopped dedicated fans from theorizing who might be responsible.

In contrast to the gentle reintroduction of characters in Hallmark’s When Calls the Heart Season 12, The Way Home dives headfirst into captivating mysteries from the outset. The storyline intricately weaves through the experiences of three generations of women—Del, her daughter Kat, and Kat’s teenage daughter, Alice, who is 17 years old when the series begins.

The season opener captures Alice returning home from Minneapolis, only to plunge suddenly into a watery predicament. While the show has kept the identity of her attacker a secret, fan speculation runs rampant as they piece together clues from the episode.

Possible Connections to the 1970s in The Way Home Season 3

Given the show’s unique narrative structure that spans two timelines—present day and 1974—viewers have begun to theorize that Alice might be trapped in a cyclical predicament, possibly even as her own assailant, prompting her journey back to the past. As one fan aptly noted on Reddit, “What if future Alice comes back in time to push herself into the pond? Thus ensuring she goes back to the 70s.”

Alice in The Way Home Season 3 — Image Credit: Hallmark

This theory gains traction when, during her visit to the pond with Kat, Alice observes, “Someone other than us is using the pond.” Additionally, Jacob’s recollection of Colton’s warning not to visit the pond introduces further layers of intrigue without directly implicating him.

Fans are eagerly piecing together the evidence. Another contributor mentioned that “the reflection of the figure in the water looked kind of like the woman from the teaser scene, which I think is Alice.” This has prompted discussions about the potential for time travel, as echoed by other viewers commenting on the precedent set by earlier appearances of teenage Del and Kat in 1974.

Moreover, the list of potential suspects does not begin and end with a future Alice. One fan raised an intriguing possibility: “I wonder if it could be Casey? When Alice noticed someone running, it looked like they had short hair like Casey. Wish next Friday was here already!” This further fuels the conversation about who might be behind the startling event.

While the mystery unfolds, viewers are kept guessing about the assailant’s identity, which seems to point towards a female culprit. Fans are left to wonder if the upcoming episode, The Way Home Season 3 Episode 2, will finally unveil the truth.

You can catch up on Seasons 1 and 2 of The Way Home available on the app, with Season 3 releasing new episodes weekly. For fans seeking similar themes and vibes, shows like Virgin River Season 7 and Sullivan’s Crossing Season 3 may pique your interest.

Source & Images