Top 5 Anime Characters Who Had More Traumatic Childhoods than Naruto (& 5 Who Can’t Comprehend His Suffering)

The childhoods of anime characters can dramatically influence their journeys and resilience in life. While Naruto Uzumaki’s narrative of isolation and rejection resonates with many anime fans, there are other characters who have faced even more grueling pasts filled with abandonment, trauma, and loss. On the flip side, certain figures such as Izuku Midoriya and Mikasa Ackerman enjoyed more sheltered upbringings, supported by loving families and friendships.

This article explores five anime characters who experienced more painful childhoods than Naruto, alongside five whose lives lacked the depth of hardship found in his story. By highlighting these varied experiences, we can gain insight into the making of these cherished characters and their respective arcs.

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author.

Kuchiki Rukia and 4 other anime protagonists with tougher childhoods than Naruto Uzumaki

1) Kuchiki Rukia (Bleach)

Kuchiki Rukia (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Kuchiki Rukia’s childhood was far more distressing than that of Naruto Uzumaki, characterized by profound abandonment and seclusion. After being abandoned by her sister Hisana, Rukia grew up in Rukongai alone, while Naruto, despite his difficulties, benefited from the support of individuals like Iruka. The loss of Hisana to illness added to her trauma, a weight that Naruto did not have, as he never experienced parental loss in the same way.

Rukia’s quest for acceptance within the Kuchiki clan was marked by her humble origins clashing with the aristocracy, while Naruto’s battles were fueled by societal discrimination. Furthermore, Rukia faced life-threatening challenges, including a death sentence, underscoring the severity of her circumstances compared to Naruto’s.

2) Erina Nakiri (Food Wars!)

The childhood of Erina Nakiri was characterized by relentless expectations imposed by her father, Azami, who enforced strict culinary standards that stifled her emotionally and bred feelings of inadequacy. Caught in the role of a prodigy rather than a child, Erina struggled to form genuine friendships and understand her own identity under the immense pressure of her family’s expectations.

Her trepidation about failure impeded her culinary ambitions while, in contrast, Naruto, despite being an orphan dealing with societal rejection, found solace and encouragement from friends and mentors. This support helped Naruto build resilience and ultimately forge a positive identity, leading him to acceptance and recognition.

3) Edward Elric (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood)

Edward Elric’s formative years were saturated with deeper trauma compared to Naruto’s. He faced the devastating absence of his father, the death of his mother, and the dire repercussions of dabbling in forbidden alchemy, which cost him his limbs and brought about his brother Alphonse’s suffering. This guilt has relentlessly haunted Edward, motivating his pursuit of redemption throughout the series.

While Naruto grappled with extreme loneliness and social alienation, he did not endure the same intense personal loss and guilt that Edward faced. Naruto’s storyline revolved around seeking acceptance, whereas Edward’s struggle was intrinsically tied to the heavy emotional and physical wounds of his past, revealing how profound his trauma was compared to Naruto’s experiences.

4) Lucy (Elfen Lied)

Lucy from Elfen Lied navigated a far more traumatic childhood than Naruto Uzumaki. Subjected to extreme cruelty and experimentation, she developed a deep-seated hatred for humanity. Isolated from both humans and her own race, Lucy’s existence was devoid of love and support, leading to the fragmentation of her personality as a means of coping with unbearable pain.

In stark contrast, although Naruto was an orphan facing ostracism, he did not endure the same level of physical abuse. With guidance from mentors like Iruka, Naruto aspired for recognition through constructive efforts, moving towards becoming a hero. Conversely, Lucy remained ensnared within a cycle of violence and psychological suffering.

5) Touka Kirishima (Tokyo Ghoul)

Touka Kirishima (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Touka Kirishima experienced a more challenging childhood than Naruto Uzumaki due to significant losses and feelings of isolation. After losing her mother and then witnessing her father’s vengeful death, Touka was left feeling abandoned and weighed down by guilt.

Struggling with her identity as a ghoul, she suppressed her true self, leading to severe self-hatred and insecurity. Betrayed by someone she trusted added to her isolation, making her defensive and hesitant to form bonds with others.

On the other hand, even though Naruto faced abandonment, he had supportive figures in his life and ultimately carved out strong friendships, using hard work and determination to emerge from the shadows of his past.

Izuku Midoriya and 4 other anime characters with preferable childhoods compared to Naruto Uzumaki

1) Izuku Midoriya (My Hero Academia)

Izuku Midoriya enjoyed a markedly less tumultuous childhood than Naruto Uzumaki. With a caring mother, Inko, Izuku experienced emotional stability and a strong sense of personal identity, knowing his father loved him, despite being Quirkless. In contrast, Naruto was an orphan ostracized due to the Nine-Tails sealed within him, which resulted in profound feelings of loneliness.

Throughout his life, although the anime character faced bullying, he also cultivated meaningful friendships that contributed to his growth. In comparison, Naruto’s quest for acceptance was often fraught with conflict and a desperate hunger for recognition, rendering his path to heroism far more arduous than that of Izuku.

2) Jonathan Joestar (Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure)

Jonathan Joestar (Image via David Productions)

Jonathan Joestar’s early life presented distinct challenges compared to Naruto Uzumaki, with Jonathan enjoying the comforts of a more privileged upbringing. Raised in a wealthy English household, he received love and support from his father, George, which helped cultivate resilience amid adversity, particularly in his rivalry with Dio.

Conversely, Naruto’s plight as an orphan led to his being shunned by villagers due to the Nine-Tails Fox within him, thrusting him into a life of profound loneliness and a desperate pursuit of acceptance. While Jonathan navigated his life with confidence and nurturing relationships, Naruto contended with emotional turmoil and feelings of abandonment, emphasizing the vast difference between their experiences.

3) Kagome Higurashi (InuYasha)

Kagome Higurashi (Image via Sunrise Studio)

Kagome Higurashi had a significantly easier upbringing compared to Naruto Uzumaki, largely thanks to her supportive family. Surrounded by her mother, grandfather, and brother, Kagome received the emotional support necessary to help her embrace her role as a miko.

In contrast, Naruto endured severe isolation because of the presence of the Nine-Tailed Fox, resulting in deep-seated loneliness. While Kagome formed positive friendships throughout her youth, Naruto fought for acceptance and often faced ridicule. Ultimately, Kagome’s emotional resilience stemmed from her nurturing environment, in stark contrast to Naruto’s struggles with identity and rejection.

4) Gon Freecss (Hunter X Hunter)

Gon Freecss (Image via Madhouse Studios)

Gon Freecss enjoyed a comparatively easier childhood than Naruto Uzumaki. Raised on Whale Island by his aunt Mito, Gon experienced a nurturing and supportive environment, while Naruto grew up as an orphan, ostracized due to the demon fox sealed within him.

The anime character’s upbringing was filled with innocence and adventure, devoid of grave trauma, while Naruto’s youth was marred by bullying and emotional scars. Gon’s motivations were rooted in curiosity and the desire to find his father, in contrast to Naruto’s need for belonging. Additionally, Gon’s natural abilities facilitated his skill development, whereas Naruto relied on hard work to overcome his challenging circumstances.

5) Mikasa Ackerman (Attack on Titan)

Mikasa Ackerman and Naruto Uzumaki experienced significantly different childhoods that influenced their development. After the tragic loss of her parents, Mikasa found a new home with Eren’s family, which afforded her emotional security and support. Meanwhile, Naruto endured isolation as an orphan, often ostracized by the villagers because of the sealed Nine-Tailed Fox.

Although Mikasa underwent rigorous training from an early age, honing her skills as a fighter, Naruto faced his challenges without formal instruction and had to work tirelessly to gain recognition as a ninja. Overall, despite the tragedies Mikasa experienced, her youth was considerably more privileged than Naruto’s tumultuous upbringing.

Concluding observations

By comparing these anime characters’ childhoods, it becomes apparent that many endured trauma and isolation that greatly exceeded that of Naruto. While Naruto’s journey revolves around seeking acceptance amidst rejection, characters such as Rukia and Lucy have endured darker, more harrowing experiences, showcasing the broad spectrum of emotional hardships presented in anime narratives.

Source