Ultimate Guide to Solving the Poem and Gallows Puzzle in Silent Hill 2 Remake

The Silent Hill 2 Remake is an immersive survival horror title that immerses players in a captivating world filled with mysterious challenges. One of the intriguing puzzles is found in the prison yard, involving gallows and an execution lever.

This particular puzzle involves deciphering a collection of six poems that pertain to themes of criminal judgment. Players must uncover which criminal deserves execution by solving all the riddles. To assist you, we have already cracked the puzzle and compiled the answers for you.

1. How can you complete the Gallows Puzzle in Silent Hill 2 Remake?

The Execution Lever is essential for solving the Gallows Puzzle. Players should take the lever to the gallows located in the prison yard and insert it into the mechanism. Upon doing so, six partial poems that characterize various criminals will be displayed. Your objective is to pair the first two lines of each poem accurately.

Players must identify which criminal is guilty or innocent by analyzing the completed poems. Once you have discerned the innocent party, align the corresponding Roman numeral next to their name with the noose that bears the same numeral.

Incorrect answers will lead to a trapdoor plunge, putting you face-to-face with monsters until you can fight your way back to safety. Make the right choice, and you’ll be transported to a different area within the game.

2. List of Poems and Their Solutions

Gallows Poem Puzzle | Source: In-game footage

Poem Number	Poem	Possible Answer 1	Possible Answer 2
1	For your grace I do not plead, For the flames I did set free, Sisters shrieked and children cried, No one made it out alive.	Though the young ones’ deaths I mourn, Their tormentors are no more, On young souls the nuns did prey, Took their innocence away.	I watched them burn, I heard them cry, I felt a soothing warmth inside, It felt so good, I cannot lie, And for my bliss, they had to die.
2	The wealth of others I did take, The seventh statute I did break, And yet my deeds I don’t regret, I had my reasons, that is that.	The reason, if I have to say, Was to survive another day, To them, it was a loaf of bread, To me, a cherished step ahead.	What were those reasons you might ask, The truth allow me to unmask, I see. I crave, I need, I take, ‘Tis all the sense it needs to make.
3	I took the child you are quite right, Carried her off into the night, She did not scream, she did not bawl, I was her father, after all.	Forgive me, child, for I have failed, To save you from her wretched ways, She whom I loved, who gave you life, A monster hiding in plain sight.	My only daughter, joy of days, They wanted to take you away, Hush, little baby, and be still, If I can’t have you, no one will.
4	Once the sun has ceased its reign, I cut through the rusty chain, Pushed the door and snuck within, Filled my pockets to the brim.	So my guilt is plain to see, I had robbed the pharmacy, Yet, I did so not for gain, But so I could ease the pain.	I departed with great haste, Leaving not a single trace, Ever faithful to my creed, All is right, which feeds my greed.
5	Mommy dearest, mommy sweet, Your love for me was so deep, “Why, oh, why?” , you shouted out, When my knife pierced through your heart.	You broke my legs, I couldn’t walk, You pulled my teeth, I couldn’t talk, You fed me pills to slow my mind, I took your life ‘fore you took mine.	You were, oh, so kind to me, Filled my heart with joy and glee, In the end, it was for naught, “Why, oh, why?” , you ask. Why not?
6	I waited long, I bid my time, I waited to commit my crime, The man appeared, he saw me not, A bloody end is what he got.	In truth, he was less man than beast, And on my flesh and soul he’d feast, My will to live he’d try to break, There is so much a man can take.…	In truth, I did not hesitate, As my blade sealed the poor man’s fate, He knew the rules, they are quite clear, Go against me, your end is near.

3. Selecting the Correct Noose

Choosing the correct noose | Source: In-game footage

After deciphering the poems, it’s now your turn to cast judgment. Six nooses, marked with Roman numerals, correspond to each poem from before. Position yourself under the noose that matches the verse identifying the innocent party.

Note: Poem number 1 is a valid choice.

Once you choose the correct noose, you’ll observe James inserting his head into it. When he falls, he will awaken in a morgue. However, if the wrong noose is selected, James will end up in an enemy-filled pit and must fight his way back to retry a noose.

4. Overview of Silent Hill 2 Remake

Scheduled for release on October 8, 2024, Silent Hill 2 Remake is a highly anticipated survival horror video game developed by Bloober Team and published by Konami. This title is a reimagining of the iconic 2001 game and marks a significant return to the Silent Hill series, which last saw a major release with Silent Hill: Downpour in 2012.

Source