Uzumaki Episode 3: A Comprehensive Comparison of Anime vs Manga

The highly anticipated third episode of Uzumaki premiered on October 13, 2024. Although the episode made slight improvements to its pacing, it fell short in delivering the horror element due to its lackluster art style that barely meets cartoon standards. Additionally, the adaptation of omitted scenes was disappointing, as they received only a handful of seconds of screen time and were animated in a subpar manner.

Aside from the minor additions presented in Uzumaki episode 3, the principal story arcs adapted in this episode struggled to resonate as a decent anime portrayal. The pacing issues overshadowed any character development for the antagonists, and the attempt to convey horror was undermined by an overly cartoony art style that did not honor the original manga.

Disclaimer: The views shared in this article are solely those of the author.

Analyzing Uzumaki Episode 3 in Relation to Its Manga Source

Adaptation of the Omitted Scenes in Uzumaki Episode 3

Shuichi's father as depicted in the anime (Image via Adult Swim) — Shuichi’s father as depicted in the anime (Image via Adult Swim)

In this episode, a total of five chapters were adapted, including chapter 4, entitled The Firing Effect. It showcased Kirie’s father’s deepening fixation on spirals, yet akin to Shuichi’s father, his expansive collection was inadequately presented.

Moreover, a significant omitted portion stemmed from chapter 2, highlighting Shuichi’s mother’s descent into paranoia, triggered by her deceased husband’s haunting visions. This segment stood out as it effectively animated crucial panels, such as the portrayal of Shuichi’s father as a spiral insect, even though the animation quality left much to be desired.

The last crucial omitted section was sourced from chapter 7, which depicts Yamaguchi’s return. This climax felt particularly unsatisfactory since its placement was misplaced; it was intended to unfold before the storm’s devastating arrival in Kurouzu village, but the episode’s erratic pacing forced this pivotal moment to occur following the chaos.

Depicting the Hospital Frenzy in Uzumaki Episode 3

A baby speaking as seen in the anime (Image via Adult Swim)

This segment, possibly the most coherently paced (mirroring the manga), suffered from a mediocre 3D animation execution. The adaptation included chapters 10 and 11, the latter showcasing the terrifying mosquito women, similar to the trailers. Again, the principal issue remained the quality of animation.

Chapter 11 also started off strongly, with frightening audio enhancements added to the babies as they regrew their umbilical cords. However, the mood was spoiled in the latter portion by an inferior CGI representation of Keiko, which came across as comical instead of eerie.

The Storm’s Unfortunate Presentation in Uzumaki Episode 3

Wakabayashi depicted in the anime (Image via Adult Swim)

Chapters 12 and 13 are primarily adapted in this segment, which focuses on the villagers of Kurouzu fighting to survive a ferocious storm. Unfortunately, the depiction suffered from a muddled use of black and white artwork, characteristic of the anime, rendering the characters almost indistinguishable.

This diminished the horror impact in later scenes, particularly with Wakabayashi’s character, who, with his grotesque cone-like protrusions, became difficult to recognize. The cartoonish design further detracted from what is supposed to be one of the most chilling chapters of Uzumaki, reducing it to an unintentional comedic effect.

Concluding Remarks

As I reflect on these aspects, I can’t help but recall Jason DeMarco’s assertion about the inevitable downfall of the Uzumaki adaptation. With episode 3 failing to present any promising indicators for the concluding episode, anticipation now hinges on the official announcements regarding the creative team behind the finale.

Source