Why the New Taylor Sheridan Series Landman is Facing Backlash

Analysis of Character Representation in Taylor Sheridan’s New Series “Landman”

Taylor Sheridan’s reputation as a creator known for his straightforward and often gritty characters has come under increased scrutiny with the debut of his latest series, Landman. While Sheridan has faced critiques in the past for a perceived lack of depth in character development, the response to Landman has intensified significantly.

Recurring Themes in Sheridan’s Work

In several of Sheridan’s shows, including Yellowstone, Mayor of Kingstown, and Tulsa King, a common theme has emerged: predominantly masculine narratives and settings. Critics argue this trend persists even in his female-led series, Lioness, where the women often reflect male stereotypes rather than offering nuanced perspectives.

Overview of “Landman”

Landman follows Tommy Norris, portrayed by the accomplished Billy Bob Thornton, as he navigates the complexities of negotiating land leases for powerful oil companies. While Tommy’s character exhibits a certain depth and complexity, the series has drawn severe backlash for its treatment of female characters, who frequently appear sexualized and lack dimensionality.

Criticism of Female Representation

Among the characters are Tommy’s ex-wife Angela, played by Ali Larter, and their daughter Ainsley, portrayed by Michelle Randolph. Many viewers have criticized Angela’s portrayal as overly flirtatious and Ainsley’s character choice, which includes an uncomfortable sexual confession to her father, has generated significant discussion online.

Similarly, Cami, the wife of Monty, is also criticized for her lack of meaningful involvement in the narrative despite being played by the well-known actress Demi Moore.

Viewer Reactions

The viewer response has been overwhelmingly negative. One Reddit user lamented, “Landman is poorly written, akin to ‘misogynistic toilet paper’ based on unrealistic fantasies.” Others echoed similar sentiments, noting discomfort while watching the show with their families, particularly regarding the portrayal of female characters. One commenter recounted a scene where Ainsley behaved inappropriately in front of her father, stating, “We picked on it the whole time.”

Angela (Ali Larter) in Landman — Image from Landman, courtesy of Paramount+

Another viewer remarked on the uncomfortable sexualization of Ainsley, noting, “I thought the only saving grace would be the son working with a tight-knit Mexican family, only to find they were all dead.”

Overall Issues in “Landman”

Beyond the characterization of women, Landman struggles with overall narrative focus. Critics have pointed out that the show’s plot becomes convoluted amidst a series of tense phone calls and legal entanglements, leaving viewers confused about the show’s ultimate aim. As stated in a two-star review, “It’s difficult to ever really get a grasp on what Landman is trying to do.”

Contrasting Perspectives

While the criticism of women in the series has been prominent, some viewers argue that the lack of nuance is not limited to female characters. One observer stated, “None of his characters, male or female, are nuanced; they all feel like soap opera stereotypes.” On the flip side, others contend that the representation of women in the show reflects certain realities they observe in society.

Looking Ahead

With Landman having eight more episodes slated for release, many are left wondering: Will there be any evolution in character development or storytelling? The third episode is set to air on November 24, and fans will be paying close attention to see if the series can address its criticisms.

Source & Images