10 Anime Characters Who Outshine Erwin Smith as Leaders in Attack on Titan

Among the plethora of unforgettable characters in Attack on Titan, few can match the exceptional leadership qualities displayed by Erwin Smith. Renowned for his strategic acumen and ability to inspire his troops, Erwin guided the Survey Corps with unwavering determination, often placing the survival of humanity above his own ethical considerations.

Despite his remarkable leadership skills, several anime characters surpass him in overall leadership qualities. These figures inspire others through strategic bravery, conveying messages that have the power to transform entire worlds and societies.

This article highlights ten anime leaders who exhibit superior leadership abilities compared to Erwin Smith from Attack on Titan.

Disclaimer: The following list is presented in no particular order and represents the author’s perspective.

Top 10 Anime Leaders Who Outshine Erwin Smith: Featuring Edward Newgate, Yami Sukehiro, and More!

1) All Might (My Hero Academia)

All Might stands out as a leader in My Hero Academia due to his embodiment of hope and optimism rather than just tactical prowess. Dubbed the Symbol of Peace, he inspires an entire society by encouraging belief in a brighter future. While Erwin’s approach often necessitates sacrifices, All Might uplifts others through mentorship and emotional guidance, aiming to empower the next generation of heroes, making his impact resonate more profoundly than Erwin’s.

2) Kakashi Hatake (Naruto)

Kakashi Hatake (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Kakashi Hatake exemplifies leadership through compassion and wisdom. Unlike Erwin, who often makes self-sacrificial choices during critical missions, Kakashi prioritizes the well-being of his team, ensuring they develop trust and understand each other’s strengths and weaknesses. His guidance of formidable ninjas like Naruto, Sakura, and Sasuke underscores his lasting impact as a leader, enriching the narrative through emotional intelligence and adaptability rather than mere combat strategy.

3) Roy Mustang (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood)

Roy Mustang’s leadership stems from his desire to create a better society while fiercely protecting his team. In stark contrast to Erwin, who is willing to sacrifice subordinates, Mustang values the lives of his comrades, striving to minimize casualties. His charisma and ability to inspire loyalty ensure that his followers rally behind him out of belief in his vision. Mustang’s commitment to dismantling corrupt systems adds depth to his character, highlighting an ethical dimension often missing in characters like Erwin.

4) Edward Newgate (One Piece)

Edward Newgate (Image via Toei Animation)

Edward Newgate, or Whitebeard, leads his crew with a paternal sense of loyalty and care, which stands in sharp contrast to Erwin Smith’s approach. He prioritizes the well-being and growth of his crew over strategic victories, illustrating a commitment to foster genuine family bonds. Many fans argue that Newgate’s ambition was not merely to become the Pirate King but to create a supportive family dynamic. His legacy highlights nurturance and unity, contrasting the colder, risk-heavy strategies of Erwin.

5) Lelouch Lamperouge (Code Geass)

Lelouch Lamperouge’s leadership is driven by his desire to liberate the oppressed and dismantle oppressive regimes. Rather than adhering to rigid structures like Erwin, Lelouch uses manipulation, strategy, and inspiration to unite various factions for a common goal. His unwavering willingness to sacrifice his reputation and life for the good of others illustrates profound selflessness and visionary thinking that reshape societies.

6) Integra Hellsing (Hellsing)

Integra Hellsing’s leadership is marked by resolute determination and a strong moral foundation. While Erwin often compromises ethics for tactical benefits, Integra remains steadfast in her virtues even under extreme pressure. Commanding the Hellsing Organization with integrity, she earns respect and loyalty from her human soldiers as well as from supernatural allies like Alucard. Integra’s unwavering focus on her mission to protect humanity represents a more balanced leadership approach than Erwin’s risk-laden tactics.

7) Kyojuro Rengoku (Demon Slayer)

Kyojuro Rengoku’s vibrant spirit and unwavering commitment to justice serve as a powerful example for others to follow. Unlike Erwin’s motivation derived from calculated sacrifices, Rengoku inspires through his infectious positivity and profound sense of duty to protect others. His compassion and selflessness cultivate an environment where comrades feel appreciated and empowered to grow stronger without risking their lives unnecessarily.

8) Yami Sukehiro (Black Clover)

Yami Sukehiro (Image via Studio Pierrot)

Yami Sukehiro’s leadership style encourages growth and loyalty among his team, the Black Bulls. In contrast to Erwin’s strict discipline and tactical risks, Yami fosters an environment that allows his subordinates to learn from their errors and push their limits. His unique blend of tough love and deep trust promotes individuality while maintaining teamwork, enabling him to form personal connections with his squad that cultivate loyalty based on respect rather than fear.

9) Satoru Gojo (Jujutsu Kaisen)

Satoru Gojo leads by empowering the upcoming generation of sorcerers, placing an immense amount of trust in his students to eventually surpass him. Unlike Erwin, who emphasizes tactical sacrifices, Gojo focuses on fostering growth and independence within his pupils. By blending strength with mentorship, he creates an environment where individuals can flourish without the constant shadow of sacrifice looming over them, advocating for a brighter future towards which everyone can work together.

10) Levi Ackerman (Attack on Titan)

Levi Ackerman exemplifies leadership through his hands-on approach and genuine concern for his fellow soldiers. Unlike Erwin, who often maintains a strategic distance, Levi earns the trust and admiration of his troops by fighting alongside them. His emotional intelligence allows him to understand the toll of warfare on his comrades, demonstrating profound respect for their lives. Levi’s ability to balance empathy with uncompromising efficiency sets him apart from Erwin’s more detached leadership style, showcasing a different kind of strength.

Conclusion

While Erwin Smith undoubtedly stands as a formidable leader in Attack on Titan, there exist several anime characters who embody greater leadership attributes. Leaders like All Might and Edward Newgate excel in cultivating hope and familial bonds without demanding extreme sacrifices. Similarly, Lelouch Lamperouge and Roy Mustang exhibit visionary strategies aimed at revitalizing their worlds by toppling corrupt systems. Furthermore, characters like Kyojuro Rengoku and Levi Ackerman demonstrate personal commitment to their comrades, highlighting the importance of safeguarding their well-being.

Source