5 Anime Characters with Perfect Redemption Arcs and 5 Who Didn’t Deserve Redemption

Redemption arcs involving anime characters have sparked considerable debate among fans. At the heart of compelling storytelling lies the necessity of having characters that audiences can support or oppose. A narrative truly captivates when it cultivates empathy for even its antagonists. This depth is achieved by allowing a character’s actions to unfold fully before they embark on their journey of redemption.

Consequently, some characters genuinely earn their redemption, while others experience it without fully deserving such a transformation. Their actions and the ramifications within the story, combined with their overall character development, play a pivotal role in determining their stance in this discussion.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author.

Characters with Exemplary Redemption Arcs in Anime

1) Katsuki Bakugo (My Hero Academia)

Among those who have received a proper redemption arc, Katsuki Bakugo from My Hero Academia stands out. Creator Kohei Horikoshi skillfully portrayed his character development, leading to a satisfying evolution. Initially, Bakugo was a bully to Izuku Midoriya, escalating their rivalry upon entering U.A. High School.

However, as the storyline progressed, viewers witnessed Bakugo’s gradual transformation. He began to show vulnerability, opening up to his peers and ultimately to Izuku. In the Dark Hero Arc, during a climactic moment of despair, Bakugo apologizes to Izuku, confessing that he never considered him to be inferior but, in fact, admired him.

2) Thorfinn (Vinland Saga)

Few can rival the character growth of Thorfinn from Vinland Saga. His narrative unfolds like an unpredictable journey, making it hard to foresee an outcome until the end. Thorfinn starts as a wide-eyed child, idolizing his father, Thors.

Yet, witnessing his father’s brutal murder at the hands of Askeladd transforms Thorfinn into a relentless avenger. Despite facing numerous hardships, he gradually comes to realize the futility of his revenge-fueled path. Seeking to amend his past actions, he embraces pacifism and aims to assist others whenever possible.

3) Crona (Soul Eater)

Crona’s backstory is marked by the experiments conducted by Medusa Gorgon, intended to create a formidable Kishin. As a skilled weapon meister in Soul Eater, Crona was bound to Ragnarok, a legendary weapon, and sent to wreak havoc.

However, upon meeting Maka Albarn, Crona’s life takes a positive turn. For the first time, they experience the care and compassion they lacked in childhood. This transformative journey, where Crona moves from a tormented adversary to a cherished ally, presents a touching story of personal growth.

4) Vegeta (Dragon Ball)

Vegeta is a quintessential example of an iconic character who evolves from villainy to heroism. While his transformation isn’t embroiled in complex moral dilemmas, it showcases outstanding writing and remarkable character advancement. Witnessing his evolution from a villain aligned with Frieza to the defender of Earth is riveting.

Initially, Vegeta arrives on Earth as a member of Frieza’s empire, intent on conquest. Yet, after an encounter with Son Goku, along with a revelation about his home world’s fate, Vegeta’s perspective shifts. Determined to surpass Goku, he remains on Earth, experiencing profound development, forming friendships, and establishing a family.

5) Itachi Uchiha (Naruto)

Itachi Uchiha’s narrative is arguably one of the most intricate redemption arcs in anime. His story exemplifies masterful storytelling that cultivates initially despicable traits, only to later reveal a deeply sympathetic character. While some fans still debate the merits of his redemption, the impact of his arc remains undeniable.

Initially cast as a cold-hearted traitor who annihilated his clan, sparing only his younger brother, Itachi’s backstory gradually unfolds through numerous revelations. These later episodes clarify that he was a young man forced to make impossible decisions, culminating in one of the most heartbreaking sacrifice scenes in anime history.

Characters Unworthy of Redemption Arcs

1) Endeavor (My Hero Academia)

On the contrary, Endeavor from My Hero Academia finds himself at the forefront of characters deemed unworthy of redemption. His situation is one of ongoing debate; while some argue he has indeed redeemed himself, others firmly disagree.

Despite some accomplishments, Endeavor’s path to redemption is fraught with controversy. His obsession with surpassing All Might led him to mold Shoto into the ultimate hero through harsh conditioning, neglect other children, and inflict psychological trauma on his wife, resulting in lasting damage to his family. Consequently, even with attempts at redemption depicted in the series, many fans are left feeling dissatisfied.

2) Orochimaru (Naruto)

Orochimaru undoubtedly ranks as one of the most sinister characters crafted in anime. His insatiable quest for power and mastery of all forms of jutsu drove him to undertake unimaginable extremes to fulfill his ambitions. Despite being recognized as a prodigy, he descended into a life of cruelty through his twisted experiments.

His assault on Konoha, which led to the demise of the Third Hokage, pushed the limits of villainy. Although he later steps back and is monitored closely, his heinous actions render him unworthy of any form of redemption.

3) Annie Leonhart (Attack on Titan)

Similarly, Annie Leonhart from Attack on Titan finds herself in a mixed narrative regarding redemption. Initially, her emotionally detached and stoic demeanor evoked more scorn than sympathy among viewers, particularly post-revelation of her identity as the Female Titan.

Although the circumstances surrounding her actions are explored, ultimately, the story does not offer her a redemption arc. This decision aligns with her character, suggesting that her journey may not necessitate redemption as the lines between good and evil can often blur.

4) Laxus Dreyar (Fairy Tail)

Laxus Dreyar’s actions during the series firmly place him among the characters lacking merit for redemption. Upon his return, he seizes control of the city and instigates chaos, turning many guild members into stone, all while showing a callous disregard for his grandfather’s life.

His banishment felt insufficient given the havoc he wreaked, and despite his eventual return, the trauma he caused makes it difficult to regard him as deserving of redemption.

5) Akito Sohma (Fruits Basket)

Closing the discussion is Akito Sohma from Fruits Basket, a character whose actions warrant skepticism regarding redemption. Although Akito’s later remorse is evident, the severity of past misdeeds cannot easily be overlooked.

Her fits of rage and subsequent harm caused to others were accompanied by a lack of genuine remorse, often believing her societal status justified her behavior. The lasting scars inflicted on family members, particularly Isuzu, further complicate any notions of forgiveness.

Source