Highguard Faces Review-Bombing as Steam Rating Takes a Dive

Newly launched free-to-play shooter Highguard has faced a wave of criticism on Steam, receiving a “Mostly Negative”rating within hours of its release. This abrupt backlash has resulted in the game plummeting to the negative label, indicating widespread dissatisfaction among players.

Launch Turmoil: A Rocky Road for Highguard

The journey to Highguard’s launch has been anything but smooth. Its significant presence at the 2025 Game Awards, which was intended to underscore its potential, inadvertently fueled negativity as many gamers reacted unfavorably to its showcasing. This poor reception potentially set the stage for the game’s early demise in public opinion.

Moreover, the lack of communication before the launch hindered interest generation. As discussions mounted, many players formed preconceived notions of the game, often dismissing it entirely before engaging with its content. Given the entrenched perspectives of potential players, the rapid onset of negative reviews was somewhat expected.

Reacting to Review Bombing

At the time of writing, over 9, 000 reviews have been submitted, with approximately 7, 200 leaning negative. Notably, most of these critiques come from players who have logged less than an hour of gameplay. This trend underscores a tendency to judge the product without fully immersing in its gameplay elements.

Highguard Mostly Negative review rating on Steam — Steam / Wildlight Entertainment

Steam users have rapidly expressed their dissatisfaction through negative reviews for Highguard.

Some critiques appear to stem from genuine dissatisfaction with game mechanics, specifically the 3v3 structure. Critics have purported that this format is ill-suited for a shooter, advocating for larger team sizes instead. Yet, a significant portion of the reviews indulge in mockery, reflecting players’ frustrations rooted in the preceding weeks of silence.

One review expressed dismay with the game, stating, “Utter garbage, ”without elaborating, while another declared it “truly awful.”An additional user even speculated whether Highguard was developed by ex-Apex Legends creators, attributing its perceived lack of uniqueness to an identity crisis of merging various game genres.

Despite calls for refunds—a notion rendered moot by the game’s free-to-play model—players are encouraged to approach these criticisms with skepticism. As is common in online shooters, initial experiences can be deceiving; finding one’s rhythm often takes more than just a few matches. There is a chance that the “Mostly Negative”rating may fluctuate as an influx of new players continue to voice their opinions.

A Silver Lining? Positive Early Impressions

Interestingly, our early preview of Highguard revealed promising aspects that diverge from the predominant negativity. The solid gunplay mechanics and innovative game design have left us eager for further exploration. With the potential for growth and improvement, there may be hope that Highguard can reclaim its reputation in the gaming community.

Source & Images