Indie Game Developer Urges Players to Cease Positive Review “Attack” on Steam

In a recent development, the cozy life simulation game Starsand Island has urged its community to refrain from posting suspiciously positive reviews on Steam. This request arises amid a challenging launch phase, during which numerous near-identical reviews began surfacing almost instantaneously.

The timing could not have been more critical for the game’s release, especially given that some Kickstarter backers—particularly those at higher support tiers—faced delays in receiving their game keys. These supporters found themselves navigating through Discord moderators and Kickstarter support channels while the development team tackled distribution challenges. Simultaneously, both influencers and new gamers were already showcasing their gameplay experiences.

An Unprecedented Surge in Reviews

In a surprising twist, Starsand Island experienced an influx of “Overwhelmingly Positive” reviews, although not of the type developers aspire to receive. This issue was brought to light by gaming content creator Play with Josh, who pointed out the unusual timing and similarities of the reviews. He remarked, “In the span of 30 minutes, Starsand Island got all these positive reviews from users who happen to all have the same account activity, ” urging Steam to investigate.

If you need a larger sample, here’s about 100 of them, and there are more.@Steam please look into this.https://t.co/VmgZn6Vmvk pic.twitter.com/rMa9Do7kfL

— Josh (@Playwith_Josh) February 12, 2026

Among these reviews, one user commented, “The game is very simple, yet it is complex. Beautiful Game.” Another indicated, “If the price is fair for an indie game, I’m definitely buying, ” while yet another expressed, “The game has huge potential, and I’m definitely buying it on launch day.” The latter two comments raised eyebrows, as Steam policy prohibits posting reviews for games that users do not own.

Community reactions were swift on Reddit, with players commenting on the situation. One user stated, “Oooy. This is so shady. They didn’t have to do this, ” highlighting a disconnect between the continued bugs in the game and the sudden influx of positive feedback. Another expressed confusion over the necessity of such tactics, given that genuine positive reviews were likely to emerge organically over time.

In light of the controversy, the Starsand Island development team released a statement on Steam titled “Announcement Regarding Artificial Comments”. Initially, they mistook the flood of reviews for genuine recognition. However, they later noted patterns such as short gameplay times, clustered review timestamps, and language that resembled AI-generated content. While they acknowledged a lack of concrete evidence of malicious intent, they observed that certain accounts had refunded the game after posting their reviews.

“We simply want to focus on building a good product, ” the team expressed.“To whoever may be behind this, please stop.” They also indicated that a follow-up communication would address the primary concerns raised by their community.

Source & Images