I-DLE’s Latest Comeback: Addressing Plagiarism Controversies

K-pop Group I-DLE Faces Plagiarism Allegations Amid Comeback

The K-pop girl group I-DLE, formerly recognized as (G)I-DLE, is once again in the spotlight, but not for the reasons they had hoped. Following their highly anticipated comeback, the group has become embroiled in allegations of plagiarism, straining their recent momentum.

Launch of “Girlfriend”MV and an Anniversary Celebration

On May 8, I-DLE ushered in a new chapter with the debut of their music video for “Girlfriend.”This marked the occasion of their seventh debut anniversary and the official rebranding to I-DLE. However, the release was quickly eclipsed by controversy.

GIDLE Faces a Series of Plagiarism Controversies in Their Latest Comeback

Accusations Drawn from Visuals

Online discussions among fans have highlighted striking similarities between I-DLE’s new concept visuals and those of Red Velvet’s Seulgi from her solo project, “Accidentally On Purpose, ” released in March 2025. Critics pointed to various aspects, including styling, color schemes, and even poses, suggesting the resemblances were too close for comfort. Particularly noted were Minnie’s blue fur jacket and heavy makeup, alongside Soyeon’s car-themed visuals featuring a pink scarf, both of which echoed Seulgi’s fashion choices.

Context of Recent Changes within the Group

This controversy surfaces at a pivotal juncture for I-DLE, who have recently re-released their older tracks without former member Soojin, following allegations related to past bullying. The intent behind this rebranding effort aimed to symbolize a fresh start, yet these new accusations about originality have sparked heated discussions regarding the group’s creative evolution and direction.

Historical Context of Plagiarism Claims

The recent allegations have revisited earlier controversies, notably when Soyeon, the group’s leader and principal songwriter, faced criticism in 2022. Her composition, “SUN, ”intended for MBC’s “My Teenage Girl, ” was scrutinized for its apparent similarities to ATEEZ’s track “Wave.”Though Cube Entertainment acknowledged the likeness and subsequently credited ATEEZ’s producing team, this move generated significant backlash, particularly because it unfolded without the consent of the involved parties. Moreover, it was later revealed that Soyeon had registered the song under her name with the Korea Music Copyright Association (KOMCA), further complicating the group’s standing amidst allegations of lacking originality.

Previous Controversies and Impacts on Reputation

I-DLE has also been accused of echoing BLACKPINK’s performance style during their 2023 Jingle Ball appearance, with critics noting striking similarities in both performance concept and vocal delivery during the introduction.

Call for Artistic Integrity and Originality

As I-DLE advances with their “We Are” project, fans and industry observers advocate for a clearer and more authentic artistic approach. While none of the allegations have led to formal legal action yet, the series of controversies poses a threat to the group’s carefully cultivated reputation as a self-sufficient act—an identity they have proudly embraced.

Source & Images