Rare 2008 Nintendo DS Title Nears Metacritic’s Top Ranking

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 holds the title for the highest user score on Metacritic, but it’s now facing an unexpected challenge from the Nintendo DS game, Disney’s Cory in the House. This quirky title has surged to an impressive user score of 9.4, surpassing renowned classics such as Silent Hill 2 and The Witcher 3. Notably, other acclaimed games like The Last of Us, The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask, and Baldur’s Gate 3 have only managed to achieve a user score of 9.2.

The only title currently outperforming Cory in the House is Clair Obscur, boasting a remarkable score of 9.5 since its release in 2025. As the landscape of game reviews is continually evolving, Cory in the House is tightening its grip on the leaderboards.

Cory in the House Targets Clair Obscur’s Dominance

This raises an intriguing question: Why has Cory in the House garnered such a dedicated following? Despite its 2008 release and the fact that many gamers may not have played this stealth adventure—based on the spin-off of That’s So Raven—the game was initially met with tepid reviews. Two reviews on Metacritic rated it a mere 3 and 4 out of 10 respectively.

Yet, the title has evolved into a popular internet phenomenon. In 2013, a playful campaign on 4chan labeled it an “anime game, ”leading to an astonishing user score surge to 9.5. Although this score dipped over the years, dedicated fans helped maintain its high standing by leaving glowing reviews.

Why is this game currently on top 2? by u/Additional-Ad4567 in videogames

Interestingly, in January 2026, an unexplained revival occurred as numerous new reviews with perfect 10/10 ratings began to appear, praising its artistry and cultural significance. Comments such as “This is the greatest piece of art to ever grace humankind” emerged, reflecting a humorous yet intense fan loyalty.

A segment of passionate fans is even resorting to review bombing Clair Obscur, claiming, “This game does NOT deserve the 9.5; it should belong to a masterpiece like Cory in the House on DS.”

If this momentum continues, Cory in the House could very well surpass Clair Obscur as Metacritic’s top-rated game in the near future. The year 2026 promises to be an exciting chapter in gaming history.

Source & Images