Unresolved Major Plothole in Yellowstone: Will It Ever Be Explained?

As the saga of Dutton Ranch comes to a close, one lingering question persists among *Yellowstone* enthusiasts regarding the fate of Jamie Dutton. (Spoiler Alert: Major plot revelations ahead!)

In a culmination of years fraught with emotional strife and cruelty, Jamie Dutton met a tragic end in the series finale. Although viewers had anticipated his fate for quite some time, a substantial number of fans still believe this outcome was unwarranted.

The intense rivalry between Beth and Jamie reached its peak during John Dutton’s funeral. An explosive confrontation ensued at Jamie’s residence, culminating in a brutal struggle that concluded with Beth fatally stabbing Jamie, while Rip restrained him.

Concerns Over Jamie Dutton’s Security Measures

Beth’s assault on Jamie marks not the first instance of her aggression towards him. Throughout the series, she has openly threatened him multiple times, often in front of witnesses.

Such preceding threats should have positioned her as the prime suspect in any untoward incidents involving Jamie, particularly given his prominent role as Attorney General. This raises the question: how could he be so lacking in security?

Wes Bentley as Jamie Dutton in Yellowstone — Photo Credit: Paramount

Fans have pointed out that considering the real threat Beth posed—even expressing she would have him killed—Jamie should have deployed at least minimal security measures. Yet, he appeared entirely vulnerable to her intrusion.

Moreover, the investigation following Jamie’s death raises further concerns, as no apparent red flags were identified regarding Beth’s narrative. This begs an important question: How did she manage to evade accountability?

One astute viewer remarked on Reddit, “How does the AG’s residence lack any sort of surveillance or witnesses? If I recall, the event unfolded in broad daylight, akin to a common individual living in a suburban neighborhood.”

Yellowstone Season 5 Part 2: Wes Bentley as Jamie Dutton standing behind a podium — Photo Credit: Paramount

Another viewer highlighted, “Even if locals declared there was nothing suspicious about a person who had previously threatened the AG appearing at his residence, the Feds would surely investigate a potential governor’s assassination.”

“Lack of security for the AG is bewildering,” one viewer commented. “Even if he couldn’t secure funding, it’s reasonable to presume he would have invested in his own protection, particularly after everything. The absence of precautions and the seeming lack of witnesses are bewildering.”

With such glaring oversight, it is puzzling how Jamie managed to live without basic surveillance—especially when even a modest doorbell camera could have provided crucial evidence.

This begins to peel away the complexities surrounding Jamie’s demise. For a broader exploration, consider delving into how the series finale could potentially render future spin-offs moot, reflecting on *Yellowstone*’s most shocking moments, and what lies ahead in the upcoming series, *The Madison*.

Source & Images