Viewers Frustrated Again by Yellowstone’s Treatment of Jimmy

Jimmy, a longstanding target for many characters in *Yellowstone*, has garnered significant attention in Season 5, Episode 12, with fans expressing frustration over his treatment.

While initially the most inexperienced ranch hand on the Dutton Ranch, Jimmy has found a foothold among many viewers. His transformative journey—from a bewildered newcomer to a confident cowboy—has often been hailed as one of Taylor Sheridan’s notable achievements within the series.

Nevertheless, the recent installment of *Yellowstone* has seemingly regressed much of Jimmy’s character development, prompting criticism from the audience.

Jimmy’s Character Regression in Season 5

At the onset of this episode, when Jimmy meets up with Travis, the horse wrangler—a character written by Sheridan himself—he is met with a barrage of insults, starting with criticism over the bit he incorrectly fitted on a horse. Despite having valuable experience from his stint at the renowned 6666 Ranch, the encounter paints Jimmy as inept.

In a poignant moment that follows, Travis receives news of John Dutton’s passing and takes a moment to inform Jimmy. He compassionately offers him a week off to cope with the emotional fallout. Showcasing his growth, Jimmy declines the offer and chooses to saddle up again, demonstrating his resilience.

Jefferson White as Jimmy in Yellowstone — Paramount

However, the earlier scene has left many viewers disgruntled. Fans are disappointed to see Jimmy revert to being the punchline of jokes rather than embracing his development. Comments from the audience reflect this sentiment:

“My least favorite part of this season. Jimmy’s character development was one of the best parts of the show; turning him into the butt of the joke again is a waste,” one viewer remarked on the show’s subreddit.
“Yeah, kinda kills that whole redemption storyline,” another commented, expressing concern over the handling of the narrative.
“I hate his story arc. He went to Texas, became a more proficient cowboy, and now he’s back to being an idiot. They did him dirty,” stated a third viewer.
“I hate Taylor’s regression of Jimmy. It’s beyond frustrating and not funny; it’s just cringe-worthy. They should have written him out of the show if they were going to regress his character,” another fan added.

Looking ahead, fans can anticipate more of Jimmy in the upcoming *Yellowstone* spinoff, *6666*. Viewers are hopeful that in this new narrative, he will finally achieve the respect he deserves among his peers.

Stay tuned for the release date of the next *Yellowstone* episode. Additionally, discover which character’s demise in Season 5, Episode 12, rivals that of Kevin Costner’s, and explore why the latest *Yellowstone* and *Landman* episodes highlight some of Sheridan’s quirkiest writing habits.

Source & Images