On X, Shuhua sparked controversy when she compared (G)I-DLE to “other idols,”with opinions being split on whether it was a joke or if she was being “overly confident.”
On July 8, (G)I-DLE released their 7th mini album, “I Sway”, on various music sites at 6 PM KST. This garnered significant interest as it marks their first comeback in 6 months since the release of their second full album, “2”, in January.
The fans were eagerly anticipating the quintet’s new release for another reason – their previous record of achieving 4 consecutive “Perfect All-Kills”on the domestic music charts. This impressive feat began with their hit song “TOMBOY”in 2022, followed by “NUDE,””Queencard,”and “Fate.”
Despite this, there is a high level of anticipation that they will dominate the summer charts and potentially break their previous records with their latest release, “KLAXON.”
(G)I-DLE’s “Klaxon” has failed to chart on Spotify Daily Top Songs Global as the song garnered 338,573 unfiltered streams in its first day. pic.twitter.com/IgGosS3ukF
— Nong Yi Hok #HotMess ❤️🔥 (@MiLLiZAENA) July 9, 2024
However, much to the disappointment of music fans, the song did not receive as much support as expected upon its release. Even on Spotify, it was unable to enter the Daily Top Songs Global as of July 10.
Despite their disappointing rankings on music charts and lackluster reception from music enthusiasts, this sparked a heated debate among netizens. As a result, some fans resurfaced Shuhua’s initial statement during their comeback Livestream.
The (G)I-DLE members were discussing the song in a snippet that was being shared on social media. They described it as “addictive”and expressed their hope that it would be a constant summer anthem for them.
Nah ik someone is super embarrassed 😭😭 “sorry to other idols”https://t.co/slLQFnyG3L pic.twitter.com/TGB8PXq1OL
— Æ… HOT MESS (@karosa00_) July 9, 2024
Upon hearing this, Shuhua interjected:
“Sorry to other idols.”
After being uploaded, the clip quickly gained over 3.6 million views, causing many viewers to feel offended by the star’s remark.
Shuhua was ridiculed for her “excessive confidence”and faced criticism for attempting to compete with other K-pop idols. Netizens also accused her of lacking talent and suggested she should be ashamed for her statements.
she’s literally the most talentless mainstream idol like 😭 her ass needs to sit down https://t.co/MWFojyElm4
— ijbol || idgaf || ifb (@jisooismother) July 10, 2024
“We improve by comparing ourselves to our past rather than competition. I love that every artist has their own color and charm, so I don’t think it can be compared.” — Ningning”Sorry other idols, everybody will only be listening to our songs this summer”— (G)-idle https://t.co/swvfqQF1he
— aetridem (@aetridem) July 9, 2024
sing for us firstpic.twitter.com/6v2aXCuId8 https://t.co/EtxH7Fylug
— 🦋ningning madonna kiof🦋 (@babynyz) July 10, 2024
Even though you said she was just joking, is that a nice thing for an idol to say in front of the camera? All fans of various idols probably think it’s not a joke. That’s fine, if for example the results are according to her wishes, but what if not? 😭
— bluuu🫧 (@callmesals_) July 10, 2024
As the criticism grew more intense, Neverlands (fandom) rose to the defense of the idol and clarified that Shuhua’s statement was clearly meant in jest. Fans also expressed concerns about a potential double standard, as they viewed her comment as a “threat,”while similar remarks from male idols are often praised as “sassy”or “king behavior.”
Nevies persisted in calling out online users who were criticizing Shuhua, voicing their frustration with the pressure for K-pop idols to appear “authentic”and reveal their true selves. However, when idols do show their honesty, they are met with nothing but negativity.
Despite her witty and straightforward personality, Shuhua has consistently faced malicious comments throughout her career as an idol.
Y’all never do this to males because they’re “confident, sassy kings “but women are evil and mean spirited alrighttt https://t.co/bTmUpT9mxA
— sarah 🇵🇸 (@ysllucy) July 10, 2024
i feel so bad for female idols, everything they do is scrutinized, this is such an obvious joke as shuhua is one of those idols who’s always talking about how they love other groups songs. you guys are truly vile people, i’m begging y’all to pick up a shift at ur local wendy’s https://t.co/3JStqom27q
— 🌬️ • are you stuck? 🦋 (@kiofcity) July 10, 2024
how come shes getting hate for lightheartedly saying this when you all let male idols say the exact same ‘only listen to us’ type of thing and think theyre so funny 😭 https://t.co/m3jPMk5Tj6
— lils 🦇 mmMmMtwilight (@hoonistism) July 10, 2024
it does not take a genius to figure out shes joking when she’s a literal massive girl group enthusiast and always talking about other groups and how amazing she thinks they are 😭? https://t.co/GkIl5G1djJ
— suri (@3yeonni) July 10, 2024
Leave a Reply