Kristen Bell Faces Backlash: “Tone Deaf” Anniversary Post Raises Controversy

Kirsten Bell is set to reprise her role in the much-anticipated Season 2 of Nobody Wants This, premiering this week. However, she has recently attracted significant media attention due to a controversy surrounding an anniversary post with her husband, Dax Shepard.

The first season of Nobody Wants This debuted on Netflix last September, garnering a remarkable 15.9 million views during its initial week. The romantic comedy features Bell and Adam Brody in a quirky love story between an agnostic sex podcaster and a newly single rabbi. Their on-screen chemistry captured audiences, leading to the swift announcement of a second season, which is set to drop on October 23, 2025. Bell’s impressive credentials also include popular roles in Veronica Mars, The Good Place, and Forgetting Sarah Marshall.

Beneath her public persona, Bell has carved out a life with fellow actor Dax Shepard, with whom she shares two daughters. In a gesture to celebrate their 12th wedding anniversary, Bell took to Instagram over the weekend, unintentionally igniting backlash for her choice of words. Caution is advised as some may find the content distressing.

What Sparked the Controversy Surrounding Kristen Bell?

The criticisms levied against Bell and Shepard stem from a perceived insensitivity in their Instagram post, where they joked about domestic violence. This particular post emerged in October, coinciding with Domestic Violence Awareness Month—an aspect that further aggravated the situation.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by kristen bell (@kristenanniebell)

Accompanying the post, which features a photo of the couple embracing, was a caption that read: “Happy 12th wedding anniversary to the man who once said to me: ‘I would never kill you. A lot of men have killed their wives at a certain point. Even though I’m heavily incentivized to kill you, I never would.’”

The terminology “incentivized”suggests a darker underlying commentary, potentially referencing alarming statistics related to intimate partner violence. A report from the Bureau of Justice Statistics reveals that 34% of the 4, 970 female murder victims in 2021 were killed by intimate partners, contrasting sharply to only 6% of male murder victims in similar circumstances.

Adding to the gravity of the topic, the Netflix documentary American Murder: Laci Peterson notes that pregnant women or those who recently gave birth are statistically more likely to be murdered than to succumb to complications from childbirth.

While the couple likely intended their post to be humorous, many social media users argue that the caption trivializes an issue as severe as domestic violence. The timing of the post, during a month dedicated to raising awareness, was deemed particularly inappropriate by numerous commentators.

Responses to the post express outrage, with one user stating, “Domestic violence isn’t a joke, ” while another commented, “During Domestic Violence Awareness Month? Tone deaf and insensitive, in my opinion.” A third individual shared their perspective as a survivor, mentioning, “Crazy thing to joke about honestly.”

Im just in shock. Why would you post this? Then Dateline said wait a damn minute.pic.twitter.com/mA0RoTYa1u

— Ruthy (@ruthyvbz) October 20, 2025

A fourth user, expressing concern, noted, “I’m a fan of hers and I’ve heard her stories. Apparently life with him was not easy and it always seemed like they worked through their issues and built a beautiful family, but this is scary. This is tone deaf and not something to joke lightly about.”

Even the official Instagram account of the show Dateline responded succinctly with, “Screenshotted.” Another social media user expressed disbelief, stating, “I’m just in shock. Why would you post this?”

Despite the backlash, some supporters have come to Bell and Shepard’s defense, suggesting that their humor might simply be misconstrued. One user remarked, “The people in the quotes have apparently never heard Kristen Bell or Dax Shepard if they think this is remotely serious.”

Another chimed in, “Tell me you’ve never listened to Dax Shepard without telling me you never listened to Dax Shepard. He’s a comedian with some dark humor. My goodness, people. Stop it.”

Have Kristen Bell and Dax Shepard Addressed the Backlash?

Kristen Bell in Nobody Wants This — Netflix

To date, neither Bell nor Shepard has made an official statement regarding the controversy, although both have restricted comments on their respective Instagram posts. It remains unclear whether this action was taken in light of the recent backlash or for other reasons. Many fans are advocating for the post to be removed, expressing surprise that it remains active three days later. Conversely, some are urging that the post stay up, stating, “Please never apologize for this… I got the joke. It was funny!”

Source & Images